92% of teenage girls are unhappy with their bodies

Yes, it’s good to have an opportunity to cool off.
Once I thought I was madly in love and went to
propose, but the lady was out for an hour, I was told.
So I went and ate lunch.
Afterwards I realized I wasn’t in love; I
had just been hungry. I ate a hamburger
and it was gone.

I suppose disatisfaction with one’s bod is,
and has always been, pretty typical of
adolescence.

It’s hard to tell much from that sort of a survey. If asked, sure, a high percentage of teenage girls will express dissatisfaction with some morphological feature or other. I am speaking as a parent of girls who are 16, 17, and 19. OTOH, it is clear that they also realize, at times, that they are hot patooties. I think a healthy adolescent will do a lot of comparing, and some envying and wishing. But there’s an underlying healthy attitude in many(not all) of those girls which will win out in the end.

I think perhaps a lot of people become real good at faking “healthy attitude” in public.

Its rare in Western cultures for men to wear makeup.
Their ability to provide for a family seems to carry more weight than appearances?

My sister-in-law
(12 years younger than my brother/her husband, is the chief bread winner in the family as my brother is an artist, and who for her physical beauty could be on a poster of reasons to visit Ireland)
once confided to me that she thought she was “simply ugly” without make-up on.

Have I mentioned this before?
My husband once asked me why I don’t wear make-up. (I think it was shortly after a visit from his mother.)

I asked him what part of my face did he think needed improvement.

He’s never brought the subject up again.

I’m at that age at which I can’t take my bloody eyes off any female who’s under 30, slim, wearing tight jeans and, preferably, has six inches of midriff showing. Especially when I’m looking from behind. This is not a male chauvinist pig thang. This is the pathetic rant of a dirty old man. So my wife says. I’d like to think I was the exception and that I had that certain je ne sais quoi that young women find irresistible. I mean, how can any woman resist this?

:smiley:

While we were out getting fast food (at some local non-chain burger joint I don’t remember the name of) a few weeks back, I told my Aunt “Well, I guess I’m officially middle aged.” She replied “what do you mean?” I said “because every single girl inside that place looks good”.

It’s like puberty all over again, but worse, because this time around, I know what I’m missing :wink:

I’m of the opinion that 92% of teenagers of either sex are dissatisfied with 92% of anything you ask them about. I was dissatisfied with my parents (I love them to pieces now), with school (I stayed in school full-time till I was 30), with women (happily married for over a decade, have a daughter whom I love to pieces), with American beer (okay, American beer has changed A LOT), . . .

I was dissatisfied with my appearance, too. Now that I’m middle aged and am shaped much like Steve, albeit with smaller arms and calves, I’m quite content with my appearance. Shit, I had beautiful curly hair till I was in my late-20’s, too; it just straightened out after one haircut. I must admit, I wish it would come back. I was hoping the grey would come in curly, but alas.

Oh, and BTW, the 70’s Show episode in which Kelso melted the faces of Eric’s GI Joe and Donna’s Barbie was on this evening.

That’s one of the most intellegent quips I’ve ever read. I just love it when women get particularly clever. :heart:

:laughing: :laughing: … :cry:

djm

Just the opposite here. I asked my (now) wife why she spent so much time on hair and makeup? She asked didn’t I like it? I said sure, but I’d much rather spend an extra hour a day with her. She didn’t eliminate the whole ritual, but it’s down to maybe 1/4 of what it was, and she’s quite relieved.

I personally think a large majority of Western women wear too much makeup and overdress. Gimme someone who looks comfortable – as though she can blink, smile, walk, and sit down without any untoward effort.

My brother, my husband, and I once got into a discussion about whether the bride (a relative) a the wedding we were attending looked pretty. (yeah, yeah, nothing like dissing the bride at her own wedding.)
I defended the bride, on the grounds that I grew up with the girl, and everywhere we went she drew male attention.
My husband posited that she was not pretty because she was too “done up”–hair, makeup, etc.
My brother proposed the “dip test.” First, you dip the subject in water to wash off the excess paint and hairspray, and only then can you make a call on whether you think she’s pretty.
I know. It was a silly conversation.

Personally, I like the phenomenon in which someone, at first glance, may strike you as non-extraordinary in appearance. Then, as you get to know the person, it begins to dawn on you just how beautiful he/she is.
The opposite effect has been know to occur as well.

Pretty is not the same thing as attractive. I think that this may be the difference in the two statements.

To whip together a terrible analogy I think that glass figurines are pretty, but do not want to get close to them for fear of breaking them (so slightly repulsive). Broken in leather that is “ugly” but soft to the touch is something that I am drawn towards and find it difficult to resist picking up. I find this to be most true in museums. Some things I stand back and say, that’s pretty, other times the glass case keeps me from getting kicked out.

As for not being happy with one’s body, I don’t think that this is a bad thing. I think it is more the way that you deal with it.

Another bad analogy
Are you satisfied with your income? If not you could do several different things.

You could work hard and improve your worth and perhaps your salary.
You could rob a bank.
You could hang out with people poorer than you and make fun of them.
If you cannot do anything to improve your income, perhaps your expectations need to be adjusted.

I think that it is more what you do about your dissatisfaction that can be a problem. In the article, the girl would eat when sad, (not a healthy outlet) others would starve themselves, (again not the best idea) many companies try to profit off of dissatisfaction by selling self help books, gadgets, etc. but actually have an interest in not solving your problems and at best can change the symptoms of larger problems (not that all are snake oil salesmen). On the other hand some people use this dissatisfaction to work on their posture, grooming, diet and exercise (seemingly positive outlets). (edit)I would like to add, just because you want to improve doesn’t mean that you are comparing your body to others you may just se potential.
As a side note, it is amazing what can be done to the body these days. Leg bones can be broken and set to give more length to make short people taller, skin can be bleached by chemicals or darkened with UV, hair can be turned the colors of the rainbow, wrinkles can be diminished with injections of toxins or surgery, body parts can have their dimensions changed with implants, etc.

Wait a minute. You’ve always made it sound like you’re as huge as a beached whale. You don’t look it to me.

What are you doing in that picture, whistling through your hands?

So I can probably safely assume you are not one of those people who fly into a panic if you see a nipple on TV.

I cannot understand the absolute fear some people express over human nudity.

They watch the most horrific violence on prime time TV yet the mere thought of a bare butt or stray nipple sends the whole nation into a frenzy.

OMG. Think of the CHILDREN!!!

But back to the subject.

You haven’t seen me from the side. There’s a hint of it just above my shorts on the right side of the pic. :blush:

What are you doing in that picture, whistling through your hands?

I’m playing the harmonica. Duh. :really:

I prefer nipples not to stray, personally. On the front end of the breast is just fine by me. :smiley:

If you were living on a desert island, removed from other people and media images, you’d be happy with your body. I thinsk it’s only comparison to others that suggests improvement is necessary, desireable or possible.

I think there’s been a study to this effect. I remember hearing about a pacific island where the natives believed that big bodies were beautiful and the ideal body shape.

Then they got TV. That generation of girls started getting very thin and developing the body image problems so prevalent in the West.

I’ll see if I can find a link about it.

Edited to add:

http://www.obesityresearch.org/cgi/content/full/13/1/110

Fiji is currently undergoing a period of rapid social change in the context of modernization, increasing participation in the global economy, and exposure to Western ideas, values, and media images. The Nadroga coast is one of Fiji’s primary tourist attractions and has supported wage-earning jobs for ethnic Fijians, although the majority of Fijians continue to support themselves primarily through agriculture. Village homes in this area began to access electricity in the mid-1980s but have accessed broadcast television only since 1995. The partial shift from subsistence agriculture to wage-earning work has gradually allowed increased access to imported products. However, despite many changes associated with better transportation, electrification, consumption of Western-style processed foods, and imported media, ceremonial traditions have persisted, and village life retains key traditional elements.

This study investigated the changes in prevalence of obesity in an ethnic Fijian population in rural western Fiji over the years 1989 to 1998, a decade that was characterized by the increasing electrification of rural areas, the introduction of television, and other economic and social changes. In addition, this study investigated the association between changes in traditional attitudes toward the body and obesity among ethnic Fijian women in Fiji.

I guess after reading this (Happy Mouse) I have started to wonder about whether discontent is necessary part of life for improvement .

Within the article that Martin Milner submitted, it seemed that the statistic was out of place and somewhat sensational (to me anyways) because, within the context of the article, it seemed that being unhappy with your body is always a negative thing.

Avanutria, I have read that article before. Interesting and unfortunate.

These studies leave more questions than they answer. I have seen studies where women were asked their opinion on different men’s faces. The results of the study showed the women preferred men whose faces were bilaterally symetrical, but there was also a set of proportions that were preferred in the configuration. Men showed a similar preference for women’s faces with this proportional arrangement. The proportions were shown against full-face pictures of several movie stars and didn’t they all have these same facial proportions. More than just coincidence, I think.

It seems to me we are wired to some extent to prefer certain features in each other, and therefore have the same expectations of ourselves. When (not if) we fail to meet these built-in preferences/expectations we may feel a certain amount of dissatisfaction or failure. No doubt there are cultural influences that also affect our tastes, but I think it would be an error to deny the pre-wired element of what we perceive as physical beauty in ourselves and each other.

djm

I haven’t read all the pages so far but I wanted to point out that eating disorders have the highest mortality rate for any mental illness. They are a serious matter.

And they affect men and older people as well. You just don’t hear about it as much as you do young girls.

And the Romans were very scathing about anyone with a big willy. The bijou model was much more in vogue in those times. Fashions may change, but that’s one aspect of fashion you can’t actually do much about! :smiley: