Well, I don’t know the answer to that, Martin, but I think if you just say “92% of [teenage girls] are unhappy” you’d have a clearer picture of what it means. This thread will surely quickly move into the “stuff we’re not supposed to talk about realm,” but wanting their bodies to look different than they do is a potentially devastating situation for young (and old) girls. The pressure to have a certain body type can be almost unbearable. As the sister of a morbidly obese woman (who’s been overweight all her life) and the mother of a young woman who struggles with anorexia, I can tell you this is very sad.
It’s a shame because since I think at least 70% of teenage girls have great bodies, it means I disagree with 62% of them. That’s a lot of disagreement!
But seriously, though, I got a 12 years old niece who’s a little bit overweight, and I think it’s affecting her. She’s going to start high school this year and I seriously hope that she won’t fall in this materialistic trap and focus on her body and how she looks. She’s got a brain and I hope this is what she’s going to worry about.
As long as she eats healthy (she does) and does some physical activities, I really don’t care about her weight or her look.
PS: I don’t want to get in the “why would weight matter” debate. No matter how wishful thinking we do, the reality as a teenager is that you can really feel social pressure over your body at school, some girl can make nasty comments etc etc, and wishful thinking won’t change the facts on the ground.
This is one of those areas where people are becoming extra-sensitive.
My daughter is tiny - she has always been tiny. She is half the size of her brother (he is now six foot tall). But she is still growing, and she is in proportion. As she suffers from ASD, like the rest of the family, she is picky about what she eats. But she does eat. The school medic wrote my wife a letter expressing concern about possible bulimia. Nice that they are displaying concern, but we are happily sure that this is not the case.
And as for it being teenage girls - from my experience I’d extend it to 92% of females everywhere, at least in the Western World.
When I was younger, a girlfriend wanted to rule out the possibility that I was gay. She asked me “What part of your body do you not like?”
I was silent for five minutes, puzzling over it. It just didn’t make sense. It doesn’t, to Heterosexual men. I can’t answer for homosexual men, but I’d bet 92% of women would have an immediate answer.
Earlier this year my teenage stepdaughter’s boyfriend left her for his previous girlfriend. Her words at the time were, “I can’t understand why he would be interested in her: I’m prettier and have a better body.” The idea that personality, shared interests, etc. might have been a factor never entered her head. Of course, for most 16-year-old (and older) boys the “better body” factor is probably all that counts so in fact she was right on the money, but still I thought it was an amazing statement.
Back then my philosophy was if I couldn’t get a gal to have some sort of intelligent conversation with me, I wouldn’t even try with her…it’s like having relations with a hot air balloon…and, being defense captian of my HS’s hockey team and VP of the HS Thespian society, there was never any shortage of hot air balloons… In fact, there was one point in time where I had somewhat of a hot air balloon entourage for a few months. I had a nice pick, and I had high standards, meaning, the gal not only had to be comely, but she had to be able to read a book or two, name classical/jazz composers and their works, and maybe know who wrote The Importance of Being Ernest. I couldn’t stand ditzy girls, still can’t!
For me, there was so much more than just the bod factor.
I think this survey might tie in with the wide spread phenomena of little girls mutilating their Barbie Dolls.
When my daughter was about 10 years old I took her to a camping event where clothing was optional. After she walked around for about an hour she asked me why was it that only ugly looking people were willing to take their clothing off.
That comment presented a marvelous occasion for the two of us to sit down and discuss what sort of expectations one might have about how they look when they grown up.
What’s really annoying to me is that there are so many more good looking young girls these days. When I was that age I’m quite sure there were nowhere near so many lookers. I feel cheated somehow.
Yeah, it should be illegal or something. In Montreal there’s a high concentration of good looking women and girls, when I take the bus to go to work it just drives me insane. I can’t help myself and I have to look but I should really close my eyes and open them only at the end of the trip
What I learned from my own childhood and from raising her mother and uncle was to be very careful what one encourages in a child.
At some point they just might use rejection of it to express protest of their parent’s way of life.
While they were growing up my two kids had a terrible time finding things to deem uncool because I’d carefully chosen to recommend a lot of things that were already on the list of cool by their peer group.
How does a boy become an anarchist when his childhood has been spent being dragged to anarchist picnics populated by mostly “total loosers”?
When my daughter was in highschool and it was hip and cool to wear pentagrams, she’d already spent the bulk of her childhood being dragged to Neopagan festivals by her “goofy” mom.
“Boring!”
I’m just lucky there’s some truth to the saying, “the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree”.
Neither of them became Republicans
I came awfully close to becoming a Republican. Fortunately one isn’t allowed to change parties in this state during June, July, or August of even-numbered years, which gave me time to cool off and think a little more clearly.