(If ever a thread was doomed to early obsolescence, it’s this one). For all the world, Dale’s most recent avatar appears to show him laughing derisively at the post immediately above in the thread. Is this some psychological ploy aimed at those who are beginning to take themselves too seriously?
Where do I come into it? Why would it matter what I would call you to the question whether you are “yank” to an Englishman from Cornwall? You are so full of the garbled remains of a century-old grudge that you are mixing things up a bit, here. The meaning of words is not the same thing historical justice or group allegiance.
You come into it in that you’re not even a native English speaker yet you attack the way I use language and how I say things and use words (like “yank”) far too much.
I’m not a “yank” anymore than Steve is (or than you are).
I am sure I am guilty as charged. It’s fun, too. I wish I could resist sometimes. Just for the record, though, I wasn’t talking about how you use the word “yank.” Oh, but there I go again.
Well yes, you can. By claming the name that others give you and going on despite the hardships they give you can change their minds much the heroine of the scarlet letter did.
Even through the veil of political correctness you may get that name changed but any stigmas will be transferred from one to the other. This may be your point, but I find by constantly running from the image (or worse excepting it) that others give to you is a form of victimization.
Therefore the only way change can occur is claiming the name, choosing what you dislike about it, and proving to others that you are the opposite of what they initially thought.
Heheh. To us Cornishmen, “yank” refers to any denizen of any one of the many states (50-ish I believe - I’ve not kept up! ) of the USA. Should I spell it with a capital “Y” or not?
Now, my good man, “Englishman from Cornwall.” On the assumption that you’re not trying to cause trouble here I must point out that the Cornish largely regard themselves as separate from England, so, in the average pub in Cornwall, you’d be given a frosty reception for that phrase.
That’s interesting. Some form of education certainly comes into it: The problem is not just one of negative labeling, though. In referring to “yanks” I am sure that the English and Irish I hear doing it are not implying that Southerns don’t have their own identy, weren’t wronged by Lincoln, etc. etc. But the distinction that you might want to draw in America doesn’t exist in the context of an English/Irish speaker pointing out differences between English and US popular culture. There are some fascinating aspects to these vanishing and re-appearing distinctions in the language.