Modifying tunes.....

Came across this while listening to some old recordings of myself. An adaptation of a popular reel. I don’t really know how to describe it, other than a slow variant of the tune, ‘Jenny Picking Cockles.’

https://soundcloud.com/arbo-2/jenny-picking-cockles-as-air

No comments? Hmmmm? Does that mean it’s crap?

I’m not familiar with the original tune but I just love what you are playing. The timing is delightful too. I’m guessing you are playing an A whistle, in the key of B (minor)? No matter, whatever your’e doing sounds terrific. Just the right mix of sweet and melancholy.

I’m not familiar with the original tune either. The Sound page indicates a Sindt B whistle is that correct?

This is definitely not crap. I’ve always enjoyed your postings with all the peculiarities to the music whether on whistles or pipes.

This tune has a lovely feel to it… slow and graceful with an oddity or two thrown in. Just as a suggestion, being that there hasn’t been many responses here you may try posting the Sound page on some of the other internet whistle websites for more response. Just a thought.

Sounds nice Arbo. Some reels sound good played slow; this is one, Star of Munster is another.

Thanks. I appreciate the feedback. Not really a slow version of the original res. Don’t know what I was thinking when I came up with this. Anyway, thanks again for the thoughts, encouragement.

Arbo