Mainstock stuck

I know this has been discussed before, but it was at a time before I had a mainstock to worry about, and through searching, I can’t find the other thread(s).

So as the title suggests, my mainstock is stuck very firmly into the stock cup. I’d like to rotate it a bit so the stock key is more vertical. But no amount of effort on my part (that I have felt is safe for the pipes) has managed to loosten it up.

Suggestions?

Wait for winter. The wood will dry with the reduced humidity and rotate easily. It may even shoot across the room mid-tune and kill somebody. :slight_smile:

I’m kidding of course, about the killing. It’s probably unlikely.

You just got the pipes. I would just leave it for a while.
Bits will drop off and need some extra binding. Other will tighten up.

I don’t think I have received a set of pipes through the mail that didn’t need some adjustments.
When I had my uilleanns, a one hour practice session would probably include 20 minutes of tuning and maintenance.
Regular checks are essential to prevent things like this happening.
Being an instrument maker, I’m sure you are well aware of that.

Welcome to the world of “bloody hell why the nun’s arse are there so many tossing tenons on these feckin things?”

Mukade

When the stock eventually comes off, check the whipping to see if its waxed in any way, if so remove it and replace the whipping with dry nylon thread because cotton thread is absorbent and can attract moisture.

Also never wax the thread especially with bees wax or things can get rather sticky and grab hold of the ferrule when the bees was has gone cold, if your going to use wax, use parrafin wax as this aids or lubricates and does not stick fast like bees wax does.

Check with your maker as to how it is fixed - this is always the first and most important step. Far too many people try to solve these niggles without checking and end up following bad advice on the internet.

It could be any number of things (dare I mention climate change) - if made in a dry atmosphere and yours is humid the main stock could have expanded. Vice versa and the cup stock has shrunk. Overwaxed thread as Davy suggests

CHECK WITH THE MAKER FIRST

My own maker uses yellow hemp - first layer is waxed (beeswax) to grip the wood and next layers are left dry to give a nice snug fit. The main stock cup is wood with a supporting ferrule so that contact is between wood (I think it is a type of rosewood) and the hemp and not the alternative arrangement where by a plain ferrule is used for the socket. He did explain why he did this but I have forgotten

Not certain about using nylon thread as it is more slippery than hemp and you may find it does not grip the wood as well as hemp

Other thing to avoid is plumbers tape - only suitable for water pipes where it fullfils its design criteria and makes threaded joints leakproof. If use on slides and joints it will make a real mess once it starts to wear and shreds

John O’C

Last winter mine once shot off and killed everybody in Glen Burnie, Maryland.

I’ve often thought about adding some sort of adjustable gizmo to secure the main stock to the cup because of this danger. I wonder if any makers do this?

Kelly is right: main stocks often fall off in the drier parts of the year. If you’re playing on a hard floor, an expensive, hard-to-replace component might be damaged or broken.

lordofthestrings said

I know this has been discussed before

I was responsible for at least one of those discussions, my stock cup was completely immobile. Some good advise from the original maker set me straight, its a simple solution, but a lot of work to implement.

If you are confident that you can “tie in” the stock to the bag and get a leak-proof seal, then you could untie the stock, take off all the drones etc. and pop it into the refrigerator for a couple of hours.

This worked like a charm, but was a major project taking apart the stock and then lashing it back onto the bag. Maybe too much work for your stated goal of adjusting the angle, I would only attempt this if you are desperate, and confident that you can get everything back together again at the end!
JVF

I just used the refridgerator technique yesterday to remove a base drone stuck in the main stock. I removed all the other drones and regs. I didn’t remove the main stock from the bag. I wrapped the bag/main stock/base drone in a plastic bag and placed it into the refridgerator for a half hour.

The drone came out with no problems.

Jim



Jim

Those are some of the neatest belows I have seen in a long while, nice leather, nice fittings, nice finish, NICE.

Davy.

Davy,
Thanks for the compliment. I like to do woodworking as a hobby and make the occasional bellows.

Part of the reason they look nice is the pattern for the clappers came from your site.

I for one appreciate and use the info you have posted.

Jim

Thanks for the tips guys, when I go home this weekend, I’ll have to try thr fridge method (my dorm fridge is full of soda and waaaay too small.

And Jim- the bellows valve you made me is working perfectly and looking awesome! Thanks again!!