Killarney brass-bodied whistle review

There were times that I was wishing that I never left my Sindt at home.

I think you will find your Sindt is heard just about as well. I remember playing one night, perhaps fifteen years ago, thinking I was playing away unnoticed when Marion McCarthy who was sitting opposite remarked on the lovely sound of the whistle. I was mortified. I let her play a tune and was amazed at how clear the whistle sounded among the fiddles, flute and concertnas and whatever else was there on the night.

I don’t know about switching from Sindt to Killarney. I have both and yet I’ve found that I prefer certain tunes played better or easier on particular whistles. I enjoy wooden whistles vs. metal for several of my tune repertoire which isn’t very big, although I’m not a professional performer either.

Yes, I’ve heard the same about Sindt whistles Mr. G. I’ve gone to the bathrooms of session pubs and have been amazed/disturbed :laughing: at how clear the other Sindt players come through. Brought both out last night. Another Sindt player noticed the difference, especially the volume and brightness. I’ll prolly keep the Killarney as a novelty or car whistle but I have 20+ years playing the same whistle…we have been through a lot together and I have a lot of memories created with my Sindt. For example, as I explained my reasoning to friends last night, the Killarney has not been played solo by me, while being backed by Canada’s National Philharmonic Orchestra. The Sindt has :slight_smile: It would be like giving up on an old and dear friend. The differences are not that substantial to do such a thing. Plus, I like being “hidden” in the background. Sindt player for life here. Ashamed of myself for ever considering otherwise :laughing: