I complained last week about a cramped left index;
some people (Bang, for instance) kindly PMed me
about trying piper’s grip–something I have long
viewed with disdain. However I was at the St. Louis Tional
session at McGurks (thank for the photos Beo) and there was a fellow
playing magnificently with it.
So I’ve switched, both hands. I have much better control of
the flute, I find. My right hand is now entirely
free, no need for an anchor, the whole thing
is very powerful and fluid.
Also I can half hole c natural by raising my
extended left index, which is an extraordinary
advantage. Whatever dexterity I may or may
not have lost seems well worth the benefits.
How wonderful (and humiliating) it is to be about
good flute-players! In five minutes at the Tional
(I only made it to the Session at McGurks)
I transformed my technique.
Just to add, the one key I can no longer reach on
mykeyed flute is the Bflat key, cause my thumb
is elsewhere, definitely.
I see that Seth Gallagher makes a right hand
touch Bflat key, so if piper’s grip types want
a keyed flute, you might keep this in mind,
or negotiate with other makers.
Paul McGrattan plays pipers’ grip and Hamilton made a flute with keys arranged for that grip. Then there’s Garry Shannon who plays lefty (though he’s a righty) and has a piperish grip. Brendan McMahon custom made Garry’s flute.
I started with pipers’ grip but opted to start the other grip once I saw a drawing of a fluteplayer in the liner notes of a Waterboys CD. It was like a light switched on. I’ve had no hand fatigue since then whereas I did with pipers’ grip.
I’ve started alternating between normal and piper’s holds lately, as I have been having some pain in my left wrist after a couple hours of normal hold. Piper’s seems to help with that, but I have trouble keeping the flute steady, and also B rolls are harder.“Piper’s” hold is not actually the same hold I use on my pipes, BTW.
hmmm. actually, i PMed a couple of suggestions for making standard grip more relaxed. i entirely respect anyone’s choice of grip. for myself piper’s is credible and much more natural.
Also I can half hole c natural by raising my
extended left index, …
fwiw, it is also possible to half hole in piper’s grip by slightly shifting a finger to one side or the other of the hole. if the finger is held gently against the hole to begin with, it will shift and rotate up slightly to expose a tiny bit of the hole with very little effort. i find this method offers better control in achieving the “less-than-half-hole” sized opening which usually produces better tone. it also seems quicker to me than extending and flexing a finger joint.
What I’m finding is that when my left thumb is on the outside’bottom
of the flute and my right thumb is on the inside bottom,
and my mouth is in place, I’ve pretty well got the flute.
Sometimes I steady the flute with my third ring finger
on the right hand.
O well, I’m in the grip of a new theory.
Or perhaps the theory of a new grip…
I’m following this one closely. In all five days of my flute-playing experience, the relative immobility of my left index finger (compared to whistle playing) is so far the most difficult thing. I’m assuming that it will start to feel normal after many more hours of holding a flute.
If it doesn’t, I’ll think about switching my grip.
But no problems so far with my right ring finger, which had bothered me with low whistles. Yippee!
Jennie
(with my new Burns keyless, happy and challenged)
Very pleased to hear this. I figured you would be
all right. The left index should feel better
with time. My problem appeared after
a couple of years of playing and may well
have to do with advancing decrepitude. There
is a demon dedicated to thwarting
my efforts–I stay one jump ahead
of him. So far!
Maybe you all can help me. I tried the piper’s grip, but I’m not sure how to get all the holes covered. On a low D whistle, my left-hand fingers are only at a slight angle, so I can cover all the holes with the middle section of each finger. With the flute, my left hand is at such an angle that I’m hitting at least one hole with a joint and not getting a seal on the hole.
So I’ve been using regular grip, but … have been having pain all around that fleshy part at the base of the thumb and across the palm.
Any suggestions on either accomplishing the piper’s grip or else adjusting my current grip? Here’s a photo of what I’m doing right now (although my wrist isn’t usually bent back quite that much … it’s just that I was taking the photo with my other hand):
(Or could it be just a strength issue that will improve with time? I’m only just picking up flute again after many years.)
I use left hand standard, like you, but with my thumb more under so there is more support from the middle of the thumbs pad.
I use piper’s on the right hand, also under enough to get good support of the flute, and less stress on the fingers.
I found that if I use standard grip on both hands, pushing with the right thumb from the side on the right hand, as is recommended, it puts more pressure on the base of the left index finger, the part that seems to be sore on you.
The other post (the one that’s 6 pages long) about pipers vs standard grip has some photos of piper’s grip from Bang that might be helpful. It was awkward when I first started too, it does take some time for it to feel natural (I’ve been fluting a whole 3&1/2 months)!
Maybe this would help with your index finger too, Jim. I just tried the standard again and it really did put some pressure on the left index finger, much more that right hand pipers. I find it really helps me steady the flute with standard grip on the left hand, and gets me right on where I want to be on the embouchure.
I’m not sure I’m picturing this correctly … do you mean that your thumb is angled back more towards the head of the flute?
Hmmm … looks like his thumb is straight and pointing back, whereas mine is bent and more forward. He’s right … it does feel wobbly trying it for the first time. I’ll have to experiment some more. So far, I’m most comfortable with the grip that you describe … standard-left, piper’s-right (except for the pain, of course )
Yes, Lisa, my thumb seems to be angled back more towards the head, and it makes contact at about 5 O Clock if the holes are at 12 O Clock, and the contact point is the middle of the pad.
This might vary to how you find it most comfortable and supportive, depending on your body mechanics. I’m 51 and have some mild arthritis in my fingers and wrist RSI that I might compensate for slightly. And size of your hand and length of your fingers probably determines what is most comfortable too.
But, I think my most comfort is achieved by the right hand pipers, where my thumb gives a lot of support to the flute. And my steadiness comes with the left hand standard grip, also getting some support from that thumb, along with with the base of the index finger.
Yes, some experimentation is need by each, to see what works, but this might give you a place to start and at least try it.
And above all, if you feel the pain, or the strain, stop! And lay off for a bit, or find something else that works for you. Try to notice if you are squeezing while you play-it should be a relaxed grip for both hands.
My thumb works the best in line with my index finger, so I guess it’s an individual thing, what works for you is the best for you. Time and trial, you’ll find it! Just take it easy and have a good time.