I am curious about the C whistles from Cillian O’Briain Improved. They seem to have a couple of collars brazed/soldered around the tube. Two of them are over holes, but the top one doesn’t seem to be. Does anyone know anything about the function of these? The C’s appear to cost almost three times the price of a D, so it seems there is quite a bit of additional work involved in these.
Richard: I’m pretty sure @Greg-B is asking about the ‘C Improved Tin Whistle’ that Cillian makes, or more accurately, tweaks. Could be mistaken, but I’ve been under the impression that Cillian hasn’t made low whistles (at least available to the general public) since Maurice Reviol worked with him in the late 1990s, when Maurice essentially adapted the Ó Briain model into the Reviol low whistle, with his own unique design modifications.
I haven’t closely examined one of these, but my guess would be that the top collar serves as a tuning slide, while the lower two serve to increase the chimney depth of the tone holes they enclose.
It’s strange, isn’t it, collars around Holes 4 and 6.
On the Goldie Low D they’re on Holes 3 and 6 presumably because these are smaller and lower than they ought in order to be more easily reached.
Garry Somers alloy-tube “practice” flutes likewise have a collar on Hole 6, on straight-bore D flutes and Low Whistles usually the most out-of-position and smallest hole.
On High whistles reaching the holes isn’t an issue, so I wonder what the collars are meant to “improve” on these O Briain whistles.
If it’s tuning, my old Feadog D and Generation C have every note bang-on without such.