Concert Review: Mary Bergin, Joe & Antoinett McKenna

Wow!

I am still catching my breath. What an amazing experience that was last night! If there is any way you can ever do it, go see Mary Bergin live.

The concert took place in Stamford, Connecticut, in what they call an intimate venue: sixty seats at most, filled by a warm and ethusiastic audience. And the night got off to a good start right away. As I walked in and bought my ticket, someone said to me, “So, you brought your whistle.” Well, it’s hard to hide even a high D sticking out of your jeans pocket. Then he said, “Are you Bloomfield?” Again I couldn’t deny it. (I may be short, obese, and balding, but I swear next time I’ll wear sunglasses.)

That’s how I met brownja and it was great. We chatted a bit and during intermission he let me try his Cillian O’Briain Tweaked (sweet, quiet, sensitive). Nothing like meeting a fellow whistler & chiffipler…

We got two seats in the first row after we had established, by carefully counting microphones, where the Godess Herself would sit. So we were only seven feet away from her and could stare at her fingers. More about those fingers a bit later.

The music was phantastic. A mix of tunes and songs, and Mary also played a slow air. There were familiar tunes sets like Colonel Fraser/Ril Gan Anim (from Feadoga Stain 1), Micho Russel’s/Laurel Tree/Woman of the House (from FS 2), a lovely set with the Cliffs of Moher in it (and a tune called Hello, How Are You? if I remember that one correctly). They also did a set of ripping-fast Kerry Polkas with Joe on button box. I recognized about half the tunes that Mary played, and I even know a few of them. To hear her do justice to something that you’ve been butchering all along is an awe-inspiring experience. Let me stress the purity and beauty of her music. You can hear Mary’s love and respect for the music she plays.

The same can be said for Joe & Antoinette McKenna. Antoinette is Mary Bergin’s sister, of course, and the vibe between the musicians was great. Antoinette played a harp accompanyment to practically every tune, and sang some lovely songs: Fil-a, fil-a (Return, return), Fear an Bhatha, Call and the Answer, and a couple of others. Joe did some pipe solos, one of them was a lament he wrote for his teacher, Leo Rowsome, after which he launched into a couple of Willie Clancy tunes. He also did the Groves, which I understand is something of a show piece on the pipes.

Some interesting observations in light of recent threads: Apart from the harp accompanyment, Mary & Joe played quite a bit of harmony. Not on the dance tunes, where at most Joe would play the lower octave, while Mary took the upper in the B part (e.g. on Contentment is Wealth/Moncooin). But for the songs, there was lots of two-whistle harmonizing. Very lovely. Mary plays right-over-left, and turns he hands down, so that the tip of her right forefinger comes down almost vertically to cover the top hole. I saw her half-hole, of course. She covers the sixth hole frequently to stabilize the whistle. She did vent the high D (oxx xxx) on her D whistle when she played a slow air, but did not do so when she played a song air on her Generation Bb.

Ahhhh… What whistles did she play? Here’s the list: John Sindt high D, Pat O’Rioridan C and low F, old Copeland A (the first A ever made by Copeland and given to Mary by Bob Pegritz. Yup, it’s always him :slight_smile: ), a Generation Bb. When I spoke to Mary during intermission, I saw her bag with lots of red-top Generations, D & Eb sticking out. We chatted about whistles a bit and when it comes to Generations, she said she always plays the red ones. She finds that the nickle/blue ones get slippery and are not as consistant or reliable. She said she adores her O’Riordians (how do you spell that bleeping name?), especially the low F. :astonished: Seeing them close up, Mary’s whistle are all covered in bits of tape, across a hole or under the mouth piece (packing tape looks a bit odd on a Copeland). Joe McKenna, by the way, played an Overton low A and Copeland low D. The low A whistle duet on Overton and Copeland (on the Contentment is Wealth/Moncooin set) is absolutely beautiful because of the tonal differences between those whistles.

I was interested to find that practically the most common variation that Mary played during the dance tunes was bring up the end of a part, a phrase that often descends down to the bell note, up an octave. I think she does it in part to avoid the weaker low notes being lost. Also, on her CDs, I don’t recall her “pushing” long notes at the end of phrases. Very expressive thing that, and it reminded me of Micho Russel’s playing. Oh, and not a single hornpipe all night. Enough rolls to make your head spin, but not a single cran.

A last note. Mary’s fingers: It is one thing to hear her playing on the Feadoga Stain albums. I accept a lot that comes out of a CD player, “hey, that’s neat.” But when you sit there in front of Mary Bergin and you see the fingers moving, hear the clockwork rolls, and feel the irrestible pulse and beat and the strength and subtlety in the music, that is another matter. Live you hear a squeak or two, you hear the breath, there is a misunderstanding in a transition, a temporarily clogged fipple. It just brings home the fact how truly awesome Mary’s playing is technically and musically.

Wow.


/bloomfield

[ This Message was edited by: Bloomfield on 2002-07-12 12:24 ]

Bloomfield,

That’s a cool review. Thanks for all the information. In honor to you post, I read it while holding my red Gen D. I hope to see Mary in concert sometime.

Yes, red Gen D’s are very nice. Don’t let the cat out of the bag. It may drive prices up!

Gary

Thanks, Gary. I am hoping John (brownja) will also chime in with his impressions. It was fun meeting him there.

Any other c & f undercover whistlers there last night?

I have McKenna’s low whistle CD with the three of them playing together, and I would love to hear them live. Do you know if they’re going to be touring?

Hello Bloomfield,
It was great seeing you there last night. From your review, people might get the impression that you took copious notes during the whole concert. I’m impressed that you could recognize/remember the tunes. Quite a few sounded familiar to me, but sounded nothing like i’ve ever them heard before and so, couldn’t quite put names to them.
It was also pretty clear that you were much more familiar with the music, listening + playing. The more you bring to it, the more you get out of it.

I believe the five part monster that Joe played before the break was a hornpipe.

A few obsevations on speed.
There have been plenty of discussions on the board to the effect of, “it’s not how fast you play, it’s how well you play it” True enough, for us mere mortals.
These folks play FAST and well. It’s amazing how distinct the notes can be at the speeds they were playing.
They didn’t play everything fast and it wasn’t for show either. They’d play a reel at a moderate (read blinding) tempo, then just for sport, bring it up a few notches.

Joe played a tune that was fast and LONG, my ears were cramping just listening to it. It’s hard to imagine human body parts being able to move that fast, yet with control and subtlety.

re. the tape, did Mary explain why there were bits of it her whistles?

Regards,
jb

On 2002-07-12 12:47, brownja wrote:

re. the tape, did Mary explain why there were bits of it her whistles?

We didn’t talk about it. I just noticed it. Looked like she was reducing the size of some holes to get the whistle better into tune. On the Copeland A, there was tape under the mouthpiece, covering the fipple plug. I have no idea why. Also, there were marks where tape had been and than had been taken off again.

It was hard to believe that when Joe was playing you could not see his fingers. I thought my glasses were dirty because it was just a blurrrrrrr.
Great review I was wondering why you were is with her for so long.

Thanks Bloom!

Great review but you have to understand that you shouldn’t have mentioned the tape thing :slight_smile:

Maybe the board members that will be in one of her classes can ask?

And don’t you dare do anything to risk the autograph being erased from the whistle!!!
Maybe I’ll swim over to see it, but in case I don’t make it you could satisfy others that dare not ask for it with a picture?

Take care,
Ilana

P.S. Is there some webpages where I can see where Mrs Bergin will be next (in Europe would be even better) ?

I just don’t know about a tour. Sorry. And I promise a picture of the signed whistle. May take a few days…


[ This Message was edited by: Bloomfield on 2002-07-12 18:10 ]

I’d guess that there are two main reasons for the tape on the whistles. First, the whistle can be tuned by covering up the holes with bits of tape. Second, it helps on to keep a good grip on the whistle.
Chris

What a great review! Your powers of observation are amazing. I hope we all get a chance to see her live some day.

I just took a week long class with Mary Bergin in Boston, and she sort of addressed the tape on the whistle thing, which we asked about the first day. First off, she said she loves her Sindt, but only likes to play it onstage so she “doesn’t wear it out”. She played the rest of the week using a red top generation, which was held together at the fipple with silver duct tape. She said she likes to teach with these type of whistles and is constantly ruining them by hammering out the rhythm on the table for the students. And certainly she did this. lol She and Antoinette and Joe McKenna were great in concert in Boston too, so glad I got the chance to see them.

[ This Message was edited by: lawhistle on 2002-07-13 11:51 ]

Nice review Bloomfield, your words created enough visual imagery to enable me to “share the moment”. Sounds like a great concert and it was a laudable review!

The tape on the whistles. Mary told me that she uses bits of tape to “dampen” certain areas of the whistle to produce a nicer tone. As I am sure you noticed, some of the tape does not even come near the holes, but are just there to “adjust” the tone. My old ears are not that good, but I must say, every whistle she plays, be it Copeland, Gen, or Sindt sure sound different when she has hold of them.

Man, it was great to see you two nights in a row. It was also quite nice to see you imparting your knowledge on that young U.Mass girl at Harpo’s, not once looking one inch below her chin. You are just such a credit to our community!!

Now where I was looking is an altogether different story.

Its always Mary,

Bob

At a workshop last fall Mary told me that the reason she tapes up her whistles is that she “blows them out of tune” (her words!), so it seems like they start out OK, but after a while the tuning becomes worse and she has to compensate by putting tape on 'em.

Weird. :slight_smile:

Funny that in the same thread I should be complimented both for my powers of observation and my powers of non-observation. (Bob, I don’t even remember what she was wearing :roll:, but she did pick up Road to Lisdoonvarna fast enough…)

Jens, I suppose you are probably joking, but just in case… by “blowing out of tune” Mary likely means that she blows too hard, shifting the pitches out of tune. The tape is to adjust the whistles to her blowing preference.
Chris

Nonono, not joking at all - I definitely got the impression that she believed her whistles went from “in tune” to “out of tune” after having used them for a while. True, it sounds weird, and I believe she also thought so herself.

On 2002-07-16 03:25, Jens_Hoppe wrote:
Nonono, not joking at all …
True, it sounds weird, and I believe she also thought so herself.

just to remind you that none of us in the workshop, including your truly, Mr. Hoppe, and her Majesty Mary B were completely detoxicated from the night before on the Copenhagen Irish Festival :smiley:

Yours truly,
Jeroen

Surely none of us were so intoxicated as to be delusional, although I guess the little pink elephant with the low D who attended the workshop might disagree with me there.