I have made a c whistle, and tuned the length in.
I am wondering, are the c whistle holes tuned similar to the d whistle, except one tone lower?
Like this:

Would it be C - D - E - F# - G - A - B and back to C ?
I have made a c whistle, and tuned the length in.
I am wondering, are the c whistle holes tuned similar to the d whistle, except one tone lower?
Like this:

Would it be C - D - E - F# - G - A - B and back to C ?
well, yes
C major scale instead of the D major scale
Yes, one full note lower, but you will get this scale:
C - D - E - F - G - A - B - C’
(no F#)
~Hans
:snerk:
an’ I’ve had my coffee
Awesome,
Thanks guys!
I now have to go back and make sure my holes are correct.
As I was attempting to play it over the weekend, something did not sound right, whereas my d whistle was fine.
I appreciate the quick input.
Sometimes it’s best to drill one hole then play the note, before drilling the next hole…
ya probably start from the bottom too ![]()
top tip!
I did all that, but I think I put a F# in there.
If I can’t make the adjustment, a new peice of copper tubing is not too expensive. ![]()
just make the hole smaller
or move it down a bit…
Wise guys…
Not metal safe, I know.
I am curious.
And maybe its my lack of music knowledge.
Why does the D scale have the F#, when the C does not?
see here for instance:
http://www.jazclass.aust.com/scales/scamaj.htm
or google for “major scale”
Why does the D scale have the F#, when the C does not?
Cromwell stole all the F#s.
Why does the D scale have the F#, when the C does not?
down one full tone…G -->F
besides C major is all the white keys (and none of the black) on a piano
Cromwell… ![]()
see here for instance:
http://www.jazclass.aust.com/scales/scamaj.htm
or google for “major scale”
Good stuff, thanks.
Hi Salty, and welcome! If it turns out that you’ve accidentally drilled an F# hole on your C whistle, don’t discard the whistle. You’ve made, in effect, a C Lydian whistle which could be interesting to play with. The natural major scale is G Major (using A fingering), and you have other useful modes at hand - A Dorian (B fingering), D Mixolydian (E fingering), etc.
ya could have started with tellin’ him about taping over part of the hole
Lydian, have ya seen her recently?
Lydian ran off with Dorian, who has been looking unnaturally good for his age. Phrygian, who has a bit of an odd temperament, called Dorian an Aeolian, and there was discord that couldn’t be resolved.
I sure Mixolydian. I’d give everything Ionian to get her back, I’ve been so Locrian in my beer.
ah, thanks for the update ![]()
just as well I suppose
odd lot anyhow, ain’t they