I’m wanting to get myself a good bodhran. I don’t like cheap instruments; I want something that will sound good, look good, and last.
I know some of you swear by Halpin drums, and that’s an option I’m seriously considering. But $350 for a big frame drum??? A really GOOD frame drum, yes, and worth it, I’m sure, but I’m wondering if there’s something out there of similar quality that won’t put such a dent in my savings. I don’t really know where to look–there are so many Bodhran makers’ sites on the net, and of course they all say there’s are the greatest of all time…
There are so many things that come into your question, it’s hard to start.
I own two Halpin drums a 19" which I have had for six years-and it does play anywhere and stays in tune under any weather related conditions. I also now own a 26" Halpin, which I finding truely amazing sound qualities on. I also own a 18" Cooperman, which was my first bodhran and I still use it. There is also a 16" Kearns which plays well.
What do you want it for? To play regularly or on the side? Do you want a tunable or non tunable bodhran?
You have surfed the Bodhran home page of makers, and you will see that their prices have risen sharply over the last few years.
I don’t have the url but there is a Yahoo group that discusses bodhrans and you will get immediate replies and a great discussion on what is theee best bodhran.
Mark
P.S. Sorry. I am impressed with Mance Grady’s bodhrans. I have two of his CDs and the sound quality of his bodhrans is excellent and they look good to. It’s just the killer exchange on the Canadian dollar that keeps me from purchasing one. The Highlander is one that I’m interested.
You might also want to email Fred Halpin because I don’t understand his Canadian dollar listing and his US dollar price. The exchange rate is about $.35-$.40 on the dollar making the bodhran lot cheaper in US dollars than he has posted. I hope this helps.
M~
“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed people can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing, that ever has.” Margaret Mead 1901-1978
[ This Message was edited by: MarkB on 2001-09-09 12:24 ]
I just got a roundstone bodhran and it is really nice. I bought it through Steve Powers. He has really nice packeages, such as a drum, a case, book, tipper, at one price. But that’s just my opinion.
Next went to Ebay and purchased a cheap ($30) Pakistani Bodhran, which worked okay, and was good enough for me to recognize, that I wanted a better bodhran, and that my interest was going to remain. I also took a bodhran class what allowed me to play a number of bodhrans. I found I liked the Kearns best.
I then went back to ebay and started looking for better quality Bodhran’s. Here are some of the ones I found, including the Kearns - Roundstone I purchased:
Ebay let me purchase a quality Bodhran at about 50-60 percent of retail.
So I used a cheap one to sample, Ceolas to define the range, and Ebay to purchase an intermediate level. Eventually, after I learn a little more, I plan on getting a tunable.
Hope this helps.
And as always,
Enjoy Your Music,
Lee Marsh
[ This Message was edited by: LeeMarsh on 2001-09-09 13:03 ]
You’ve seen and heard my Cooperman. It’s over 20 years old now and has been a very nice bodhran, with a very good sound. I also have a cheap Pakistani drum but the skin is hard and slick and somehow doesn’t “grab” the tipper like it should. It sounds mediocre at best. I played Brian’s Halpin and liked it very much. If I could afford it right now I would get one myself!
Hooked now huh?! Wait a minute, and I’ll see if I can find my bottle of pills…nope, that’s the Ridalin…and there’s the Lortabs…THERE it is! I’m sure my phychotherapist won’t mind me sending you off a few of my anti-bodhrán-obsessive happy pills! Apart from the fact that they make your entire arm go numb for about 4 hours at a stretch, they’re fun!
Seriously, I have played many a drum in my day, and the Halpin is hands down the finest. I like the Cooperman’s, but they don’t grab me as super-ultra neat, ya know? I’ve heard very good things bout Roundstone’s instruments, but as for Lee’s advice to look on eBay…all the one’s I’ve seen there (they come few and far between I think) have gone for a lot more than 50% of retail.
Lee might have a secret he’d be willing to share with you though! wink!
Anyway, I’d stil have to say Halpin makes about the best you’ll find. Trust me…I know all about your Wyoming weather too Tom! You’ll want something durable!
Over the past few years I’ve gone through a range of different bodhrans, looking for “the” drum for me (which I think I’ve finally found).
My genaric Pakistani, Cooperman non-tuneable, and non-tuneable from Rattlin’ Bog are pretty much room decorations now. My 16" tuneable from Albert Alphonso sits on a stand as a unique-looking decoration also.
I have a 19" tuneable from Fred Halpin, that I love to play, but doesn’t get much use anymore because I get completely drowned out in our sessions. I also have a 16" tuneable by Brendan White that was on it’s way to replacing my Halpin as my favorite drum.
Then I got my hands on one of Brendan White’s double-skin drums (16" tuneable with “sound chambers” in the frame. It was pretty much “love at first tune.”
The price is more than reasonable, the wait isn’t too bad (about 5-6 weeks, plus mailing time) and the quality is superb.
Wow. I returned home from Bible study tonight, and there was a message on my machine from Mr. Halpin himself (I just e-mailed him this morning) saying that he thought he had what I wanted in stock, and asking when would be a good time to call me back. I was expecting a return e-mail in a week or so…His actually call me back, on a weekend no less, impresses me, and definitely steers me toward parting with a good portion of my hard-earned cash in his direction…
Mark, to (sort of) answer your questions: I want a drum to learn on, and eventually to play in gigs and such. If I didn’t expect to become a competent player eventually, I wouldn’t buy an instrument. Being a music teacher, I’ve long since learned the folly of starting off on a cheap, less-than-great instrument, especially for an adult who is committed to learning. I always tell my adult beginners to buy the best instrument they can afford.
Thanks for the advice! I plan on looking into all of the drums mentioned (except the cheap Pakistani drum–been there ). Anyone else?
Tom
[ This Message was edited by: WyoBadger on 2001-09-09 23:35 ]
It was mentioned that the Halpin drums can bet drowned out in a session, and this is true -IF- you’re playing in a large group…say ten or more, and there’s a lot of loud instruments. Guitars, banjos, flutes etc…
On the other hand, in the more normal session (for me anyway) with five to ten musicians, it’s absolutely perfect! And on a mic…OH BABY!!! It will rattle the rafters!
Anyway, this may help you in your decision. One other note…you may want to ask Fred if he’d be willing to make you an 18" drum as opposed to the 19" (if that’s what you were leaning towards) simply because finding a good case for a 19" is a task in and of itself! But the 18" cases out there are a dime a dozen…kinda like the average bodhrán player! hehehe
It was mentioned that the Halpin drums can bet drowned out in a session, and this is true -IF- you’re playing in a large group…say ten or more, and there’s a lot of loud instruments. Guitars, banjos, flutes etc…
On the other hand, in the more normal session (for me anyway) with five to ten musicians, it’s absolutely perfect! And on a mic…OH BABY!!! It will rattle the rafters!
Anyway, this may help you in your decision. One other note…you may want to ask Fred if he’d be willing to make you an 18" drum as opposed to the 19" (if that’s what you were leaning towards) simply because finding a good case for a 19" is a task in and of itself! But the 18" cases out there are a dime a dozen…kinda like the average bodhrán player! hehehe