A question about the Generation Greenhead whistles

Whistle
1

I did try to search this before asking but didn’t find much info.

I’m familiar with the blue topped Nickel whistles from Generation and the red topped brass whistles from them. I’m assuming the head is basically the same design but the body of the whistle is different due to the material (brass or nickel plated).

Since I’m a newbie to whistling, everything is new to me :smiley: , I’ve discovered that there are green headed Generation whistles. What is different about them besides the color of the whistle head?

Thanks!

2

Nothing. Maybe leprechauns living inside. But I haven’t noticed any difference from the redtop ones.

3

Thanks. That what I assumed but you never know until you ask.

I’d think they would charge extra for the leprechauns though! :laughing:

4

Shh! Don’t give them ideas! (Besides, an extra mouth to feed… it evens out… lol)

5

Is it Generation, or Waltons or Feadog, that makes whistles with black bodies and tan tops, the Guinness whistles?

And I know I’ve seen whistles with black tops.

6

Waltons make the “Guinness whistles.” Why I’d want to advertise Guinness on something I paid for is beyond me.

There are lots of Generation whistles now being made with black tops.

7

Some things you don’t want to associate yourself with. But I suppose they’re targetted at the same tourists that buy Guinness t-shirts and tweed caps, just to make sure everybody recognises them as tourists.

I suspect green top Generations are in their way aiming for a similar market. I have never seen them on sale here (I lead a sheltered life though).

8

Both my Feadóg and my Walton’s Little Black D have black tops. I’m pretty sure that Acorns, Clarkes, and Oaks also have black tops as well.

9

I thought I would update this thread with what I’ve found out since posting my initial question.

I am familiar with the red and blue topped Generation whistles and I had found some green topped on eBay. I then posted my question here.

Since then I found the Generation Music website in the U.K. which has a separate listing for a “Generation Folk Whistle”(green top).

I sent them an email asking what was the difference between the red topped Generation Flageolet and the green topped Generation Folk Whistle.

The official answer is: nothing but the color of the whistler top. :stuck_out_tongue:

10

Ah, I see. So for folk music we should use the green top.

I does make one wonder what genre the red top is used for, or the blue top.

In any case I’ve been doing things wrong all these many years.

11

The blue top is for Blues, obviously. Don’t know about the red one though :smiley: . Jazz maybe?
Joking aside, my father once had a guitar made by the famous German guitar maker Roland Oetter (Tony Sheridan had one of his guitars for instance and Joan Baez ordered one but Oetter died in an accident before he finished it, I think) and he wanted it with a blue finish because he plays Blues. Oetter protested but my father insisted. So to my knowledge, that is the only blue Oetter-guitar in existence. The blue faded to green over time however.

12

I thought for Blues your guitar had to be spray-painted gold.

13

Lucille wasn’t gold…

Best wishes.

Steve

14

I’m thinking of the gold Les Paul guitars that seem to be required in R&B, I suppose.

Which brings up a topic I broached on another forum.

It was said that “Louis Armstrong is jazz”.

It could probably be said that BB King is Blues.

What I asked was “who is traditional Irish music?”

Dangerously offtopic I know!

15

Murder ballads of course; do you know nuffink. :stuck_out_tongue:

16

My very first whistle was a blacktop nickel Generation, marketed as a “James Galway” pennywhistle. It was useless for folk, of course, could only play Vivaldi and Bach. I gave it away.

EDIT: Hey, just noticed I’ve reached 500 posts since June 2001. Congrats, old chap :slight_smile:

17

[Thread revival. - Mod]

That’s a great story.I recently bought a Roland Oetter 12 string guitar, made in 1978.I would like to know more about the guitar, are they collectable? if you have any informations I would be most grateful.

18

Ah, so now it’s for Folk.