I hadn’t been to Miltown Malbay during Willie Clancy week for about 20 years. Last time there I took classes with Tommy Peoples and Seamus Thompson and the classes were grand. It cost me 5 Irish Punts for the week. The classes, I hear, are still very good-- or, like all classes, are what you make of them. So my comments have nothing to do with the school aspect, and in all fairness Willie Week is presented as a summer school.
This year I didn’t take classes. I went hoping for some good sessions with great players. There were plenty of great players and there were sessions everywhere you went. But the pubs were hopelessly crowded. While great players were in abundance, too often the sessions had fifteen or more people playing.
Unless you were very lucky and/or knew someone who knew where a small session was going, you would be doomed to trudge the streets, along with a thousand other people in this small town, looking for some comfort and some good music. This was true of Cathal McConnell and Andrew MacNamara as well as those who are not intimately connected to the small world of Irish traditional music.
I did play in a few lovely sessions. I wandered into Friel’s early and had some tunes with Harry Bradley, Ben Lennon, Leslie Bingham, and Belfast Jerry. That broke up after about a half-hour. Harry had to get back to Dublin and the session was losing intimacy as more players appeared.
On another occasion Paul O’Shaughnessy invited us to a session in a small pub that had sold its license. The proprietor wanted one more (private) Willie-Week session. Since she couldn’t sell beer she was giving it away! That was a rare, lovely time: Hammy, Paul O’, Patrick Olwell, Henry Benagh, Dermy Diamond, Connie O’Connell. Some of their kids playing fiddles. We had to leave after a couple of hours but Hammy told me the session lasted well into the night.
The point is, Willie Clancy week is more like a Club Med or Doolin on a Saturday night. Crowded. Noisy pubs. Too many players in the sessions. East Durham is far more appealing, IMHO. The session are smaller and the pubs are not filled with stupid noisy drunks from the world over.
It is fun to get a chance to play with some great people during Willie Week, and for many it is a grand reunion and a chance to meet and play with old friends, but you have to be very lucky or know somebody if your goal is to come to Ireland to do Irish music. I think you’d be better off travelling to some of the surrounding towns. There will be more comfort, more intimacy, and the music will probably be just as good.
Am I being a curmudgeon?
