My whistle arrived yesterday. Having it for only one day, I offer this review…
Whistle: The Flute Maker (Ty Head) Key of D Non-Tunable
Materiel: Silver/Paduk
Purchased new from maker. Price: $49 USD Delivery took exactly one week.
Tone: Pure, bright and sweet with very little air sound, even in the second octave.
Volume: Quiet – Medium
Air Requirement: Very little. Easy to over blow.
Back Pressure: Little – Because of the low air requirement, back pressure seems to be less of an issue. Still easy to bend and slur notes.
Tuning: Measured with a Korg CA-30 Chromatic Tuner. Both octaves play in tune, however, I found that when playing to the maximum volume, the whistle plays slightly sharp. C natural plays in tune using oxxooo.
Construction: Wood is smooth and polished. Tone holes are perfectly round and edges smooth. The fipple is brightly polished, almost a mirror finish. Edges are smooth with only slight tool marks at the bottom of the curve on the mouth piece.
On this particular whistle, there is a gap between the wood and the metal at the very end of the mouth piece on one side. I will need to discuss this with the maker as I fear moisture will get into the gap and cause problems later on.
Comments: This is a nice little whistle. When I took it out of the box and played it, I immediately over blew it. It requires so little air. Barely a breath at all. First reaction is that it has a weak low end, but this is not the case. Keeping the low air requirement in mind, it plays well right into the third octave. It plays very easy in the second octave with no shrillness at all.
It feels comfortable and is extremely light weight. The shaft dimension is neither too thick or thin for my longish fingers. The fipple is not heavy on the lips and the mouth piece is neither thick or thin. It’s comfortable.
The tone holes are a nice size, not large at all, with smoothly sanded edges.
Overall: Once I became accustomed to the quietness and low air requirement, I really started to enjoy it. Beautiful, easy to play second octave. $49 for a nice wooden whistle is a true bargain. Being on the quiet side, I most likely will not be playing it in session, so the fact that it is non-tunable doesn’t really matter. Wood whistles normally make me nervous with regard to cracking. With only $49 invested, I won’t loose any sleep over the issue.
I would definitely recommend this whistle.