Taking "anchor fingers" to another level

Here, at 1:02, I was surprised to see Finbar Furey, when going from High B to a half-holed High C natural, rather than put down an anchor finger, actually grasp the bottom of the whistle with his lower hand. (He’s playing a Mezzo G whistle of the Bernard Overton style.)

Finbar Furey : The Lonesome Boatman (2012) Live Irish TV

BTW the original 1969 recording seems also to have been done on a Mezzo G whistle. If it’s true that Bernard and Finbar developed their Low Whistles in 1974, one wonders what whistle Finbar used in 1969.

Interestingly on the album Best of the Fureys: Spanish Cloak Finbar is using an Ab/G# whistle.

2 Likes

And here c1982 FINBAR FUREY : “The Lonesome Boatman” [ circa 1982 ]

1 Like

Yes, he does the same thing very clearly around 11 seconds into that first Lonesome Boatman video too. Very interesting!

Could it be to get an acoustic effect of some sort? Reflection off his hand. For his benefit as feedback or for a microphone in some context - not necessarily that particular microphone.

I vaguely remember something about high notes (and high partials) not being radiated isotropically. To do with cutoff frequencies.

My guess is that it is to avoid the acoustic effect of actually blocking a tone hole with an anchor finger, while also preserving the ability to shade using his index finger if necessary.

Finbar originally used a whistle from India. As I recall it got destroyed and this led to his collaboration with Overton.

Uses his hand on the bottom of the barrel for various effects.

I don’t know why he would block a tone hole with an anchor finger unless he wanted that effect. If he needed an anchor he could just pinkie it on the barrel. I think it’s just an effect choice on his part.

I could be wrong but I’m not going to email him to find out.

It’s not just a matter of keeping a grip on the flute/whistle. Covering the lowest hole, or even 2-3, sometimes makes high B more willing to sound. I’ve mostly seen it with instruments that have wide bores. The fingering chart for WhistleSmith’s aggressively wide bore high-D explicitly suggests covering all three bottom holes. Covering some/all of these seems to also be a good idea for the Alba low-D and for the Kerry busker/optima high-D, both of which have quite wide bores.

And then, of course, there are situations where covering the low hole doesn’t change the tone, as well as the possibilities for special effects. My point is just that covering one or more extra low holes can also be the best fingering for specific instruments.

My experience is a different one. On the limited number of wider bore high ds I have played (I normally avoid them) ‘lazy fingerings’ would not work at all with the higher notes, instead producing a squeak of a high harmonic. In other words, they don’t help but hinder.

1 Like

It’s not a “lazy” fingering to move four fingers to transition between high A and high B. It’s what you figure out that you can put up with doing when it’s really necessary to get notes to sound well. But whether you need this (and how many fingers) depends on the specific instrument and sometimes the musical context. It’s like any other situation where there’s more than one possible fingering for a given note (e.g. C natural, G#, 3rd octave E, …).

At least one of the wide bore instruments also likes the lowest hole covered for high A, which means you’re only moving three fingers between that and high B. Nicer transitions but I find that takes a bit more thought because I tend to think of high A as a note that just works and doesn’t have alternate fingerings.

The Kerry optima/busker high D whistles are very loud, which can be critical when playing in noisy conditions. Our band has reeds and brass and we play at our local marathon. Other whistles simply disappear under those conditions, and I’m not always in the mood to switch to piccolo/fife or rig a mic/amp setup. So worth it to put up with a bit of quirky fingering.

But in Finbar’s case he is avoiding covering the lower tone holes while anchoring. Presumably this is to avoid an unwanted acoustic effect of the type MrGumby mentioned. But he anchors in such a way as to not interfere with his thumb positioning and to leave his index finger free to shade if necessary.

I think Paddler’s probably right, it’s needing a firm grip on the whistle for those long half-holed High C naturals (which Finbar does an amazing job of playing on pitch; there were no electronic tricks like AutoTune in 1969) while keeping all the lower holes open.

I did some experiments playing long High Bs and half-holed High C naturals with my lower hand doing various things and I did find that having my lower hand creating a sort of “bell” around the bottom of the whistle (like the Conn-O-Sax) did have a slight effect on the tone of those two notes. What Finbar’s original intention was, who can say.

I’m going to second the fact that you aren’t going to find out without asking him, if he even remembers, or at least having the same model of instrument in your hands. I just checked with a modern (Kerry) mezzo G. I can make that C natural with a wide range of combinations of how much I open the top hole, how much I cover the bottom of the instrument, and embouchure tuning. That includes making the note with any one of the three methods by itself. That note sequence isn’t normally prone to odd acoustic problems. So I think it’s really what you feel like doing unless that specific whistle was quirky.

Mezzo G is also the most comfortable size. Light enough not to be a real anchoring problem. Easy to reach all the holes and the bottom. Tons of space between the holes if you want places to put fingers. And you’re talking a slow-moving tune. So you could do pretty much whatever you wanted to.