Sweetheart A and F Flutes

Driving back from Pittsfield yesterday, Judy and I
stopped in Enfield Connecticut to see Ralph Sweet.
I bought two flutes, an A and an F, both Honduran rosewood.
The F has silver rings, it’s quite handsome. The
A is a darker color (I wish it had silver rings too, in fact).

I use a Sweet rosewood G a lot on the street.
Maybe these others will work there, too.
The A allows me to play in D, using the G fingering on
a D flute, which may come in handy sometimes
playing with other instruments. The A has a lovely
tone and it can carry alright, being high, but I
can also play it softly.

The F has the heft of a bigger flute, and some of the
depth and substance of a D flute, but it’s higher
and easier to finger.

Ralph has both these flutes in blackwood, but he thinks
that, while these flutes in rosewood sound slightly
different under the ear, they sound pretty much the
same to a listener. Certainly the rosewood flutes
sounded as good as the blackwood models, to me anyhow,
which cost more.

Neither is lined, but because of the higher pitch
they have very good volume indeed. Of course
both have only the tenon as a slide, and they are
in tune all the way in, so I can go flat but not sharp.
However I doubt very much that this will be
an inconvenience. I can’t imagine when I will play the
F with other instruments, and the A will be in tune
with them, I’m sure.

I’m pleased with these flutes; they’re simple and good,
perfectly in tune internally (to my ear), they sound
very good, and they are an extremely good value.
You can pay a great deal more for an F flute, and
it might sound better, possibly, but this F is quite good
as is, and it would be hard to beat the A. I’m persuaded
that, when it comes to higher pitched wooden flutes,
you can get quite good flutes without paying a lot
of money.

I love F flutes. There is just something about that key that is magical. :slight_smile:

A is cool too. I used to have an A fife from Healy. It was a ten hole, much fun. I traded it off in some frenzy and have always regretted it. I have an Olwell bamboo A and, also, a Burns low A on order.


Doc

Yes, I now see that F is a wonderful key for a flute.
I think this one cost 225, with silver rings; I think
a Hammy F costs 778. The Hammy is probably
better, but this is very good…

Also I think Rosewood is undervalued.

I have a Mark Hoza Ironwood F Flute. I love it, I just sold off a couple of my Flutes, but the F stayed. I need to try more Flutes…

Jim Stone said:

Also I think Rosewood is undervalued.

Long ago “rosewood” was Indian or Sonokoling rosewood. It became so valuable in India that people would cut down other people’s trees in the middle of the night. Now some is available from SE Asia but no longer from India. Brazillian rosewood came to be used in its place. “Rosewood” came to mean anything in genus Dalbergia except for things that already had names of their own: blackwood, kingwood, tulipwood, etc. Honduras rosewood is no more like Indian rosewood than blackwood is. All rosewoods that I know of, including African blackwood, make pretty good flutes.

What they have in common is being hard, heavy, and risisting splitting along the grain. They polish to a mirror finish usually without holes or grain lines and resist cracking or splintering when metal things like post screws and key pins are used with them.

That is, they are all more or less good flute woods. But they’re all a little different.

– Don

Thanks. These flutes are Honduran rosewood.
I’ve never really understood the difference tween
various varieties, so your post is helpful. But it’s
always seemed to me that rosewood, wherever
it comes from, is bright and ‘sings,’ which I suppose
isn’t very helpful, but there it is. Blackwood
seems to have a darker, fuller tone.

But Sweet’s rosewood flutes seem as good sounding
as the blackwoods; of course this may (or may not)
say something about the blackwood involved.
What especially interests me is Ralph’s statement
that the tonal difference is lost on listeners,
and discernible only ‘under the ear’ of the
player.

As rosewood is cheaper than blackwood, and certainly
sounds good, this is good news, if it’s true.

What say yee all?

I’ve heard consistently good things about the Sweet F flutes. Did you try any of his new design Ds? I think ‘Resonance’ is the term he’s using

I did try, but it was last summer and I don’t remember much
about them, I"m afraid. Weren’t any about last week.
I’ve owned a couple of his D flutes, one in maple, one
in rosewood, both good flutes. But I suspect the higher
pitched flutes are more competitive with the best
flutes in their key, though I haven’t played the best
flutes in those keys. I think they are a terrific value,
especially given the price of a Hammy or a Healy.

The G rosewood Sweet is really a winner, IMO.

Ack! Jim I’m sorry to have missed you! Next time give a girl a chance to hang around and say hello, okay? Let me know and I’ll make a point to shift my day around a little bit.

I’ll be sure to drop a note on this board when the Resonance Flutes are back in stock…soon I hope!

Amy…