Sliding up two notes

I’ve never had any problem with slides before so I’m not sure why now but in a tune I’m practising I’m faced with going from Fsharp to A with a slide on the A and don’t feel I can stop or tongue an intermediate G. So how does one slide smoothly legato-style between these two notes? Any thoughts?

Basically two ways: serial or parallel.

Serial: Start sliding the F# to G. And before you’re done and the hole is fully open, start sliding the G to A. Then finish the G to A slide normally. Voilà. You won’t hear an intermediate paused G along the way. That’s what I’d usually do.

Parallel: Slide both fingers at the same time. But each finger needs to slide more slowly, because you’re opening up a larger “virtual hole” (i.e. 2 holes). It’s a bit harder to control, and there’s more chance of a pop or squeak as the upper hole opens. But it can also work well, depending on how your particular whistle responds.

… or you can fool the ear into hearing a slide between those two notes, either by starting the slide up from the F# and then just jumping to the A at an appropriate and timely point, or start on the F# and jump to an already sliding finger from the G up to the A. Done well, either of these can give the illusion of a full glissando between the F# and the A. It’s what fiddlers do (whatever they tell you :wink: ).

That reminds me of those (famous?) glisses in the middle of Yours Is No Disgrace by Yes (The Yes Album). Conveniently, here’s a clip of the exact spot (courtesy of allmusic.com):

http://rovimusic.rovicorp.com/playback.mp3?c=kMYO1hcfAmp-WkiY3WZehfQIxMnXLaW9NvEpt_rvU6E=&f=J

This is also a great test to be sure that your Left and Right speakers are hooked up correctly. :laughing:

Actually, Mike, here’s third way (in addition to my 2 above): Leave the F# finger (B1) planted down, and slide the G finger (T3) up to the A. Then lift the B1 finger off, to prevent the A from sounding too veiled. The same caveats apply as the parallel method, but it can be done if you’re careful.

Exactly. They sound good to me. :slight_smile:

Wow! Thanks for the thorough and indepth thoughts . . . more than I could ask for.

Start sliding the F# to G. And before you’re done and the hole is fully open, start sliding the G to A. Then finish the G to A slide normally.

Just checking, MT. Do you mean finish the G to A slide normally or did you mean to put the F# to G. If not then what happens to the F# to G slide after starting it?

Can’t wait to test these options out.