Recording yourself

Is this the norm? I’ve been trying to learn the whistle for about a year and a half, and felt I was improving, but still sounded pretty lame. Yesterday, my son finally returned the tape recorder he “borrowed” two years ago, and I tried recording myself, just to hear how I sounded to others. I was quite pleasantly surprized. Those high notes that I thought sounded shrill, but my husband assured me were fine, actually sounded rather good, and my cuts, tips, and rolls sounded much faster and more fluid than I’d imagined.
I am newly encouraged to stick with my whistling. I wondered if others had similar experiences when hearing themselves for the first time.

I’m still a newbie, but I had a similar experience when recording a tune to upload to WhistleThis – it certainly wasn’t great by any stretch, but it sounded significantly better than I sound to myself whilst playing – a nice surprise!

It’s always been an unpleasant experience for me, to listen to myself recorded. Even just talking! But, of all the recordings I have heard of myself, I am most pleased with the whistling. The octave mandolin recordings are okay, but they never sound like what I heard while the recording was done, go figure. And to listen to myself singing…sounds like another person altogether, very weird, even when it sounds “okay”.

But the whistle is nearly always a pleasant surprise! (Could this be an underlying cause of WhOA?)

I sometimes record myself either on my mp3 player or on my cheap tape recorder. I can’t get a good sense of my tone quality from them (the mics on both devices leave something to be desired), but I can hear how my phrasing and ornimentation are working and tell if there are any trouble spots.