Nope. A smoking flute trumps any imperfection even if its maintenance requires the occasional coke and doobs. Besides, this one has managed to age without cracking.
hmmm… perhaps i misunderstood the original post. or i misunderstood the intent of the original post. but, when i read it… mostly what went through my pea-sized brain was something along the lines of… if the sound makes you happy, but looking at the superficial imperfections does not… close your eyes… listen…
I enjoyed this thread. I know I’m never going to buy a high end flute. If I had $4,000 ready to spend on something, a flute wouldn’t be it, that’s for sure. What this thread did make me wonder about though, is how much additional cost would there be to making a flute look very pretty? If a person was going to spend $4,000 on a flute that sounded good, wouldn’t they spend $1,000 more to have some custom carving? I can appreciate the OP’s desire to have something of beauty, both of sight and sound.
Personally, I wouldn’t want any custom carving on an expensive Irish flute that I might purchase. I like the elegance of a straightforward design done with good craftsmenship. Likewise with violins. The best and most-expensive violins in the world are not the ones with fancy carving on the scroll and back.
Yeah, that’s pretty much my taste, too. When I had Pete Noy make my flute, I specified that all I wanted for its looks was the classic and clean-looking standard you’d see out of your “typical” antique flute. Elegance in simplicity.
I was thinkin’ more along the lines of JessieK’s Noy,
somehow the stick on disco ball tape does not work for me.
I suppose that, given the economy, having to hire a body guard
to look after the flute, if yer off to the loo or somethin’, could be considered a good thing.
I’m still creeped out by it, tho. A lamprey boom hit the great lakes when I was a kid - one of the first invasive species to get a lift in a ship’s bilge or in water carried as ballast. We’d see dead salmon on the Lake Ontario beaches, each with one or two lamprey punctures about the size of a nickel on their sides. Once in a while, we’d see one swimming in a pond or creek. Yuck.
Less is more as regards flutes. As to Michael’s attire, well he is a former Golden Gloves champion so I guess he has the balls to wear whatever he likes and carry it off