I have designed a couple of whistles to be printed on a 3d printer. Included the CAD model so people can change the design.
https://github.com/chucktilbury/whistle
I would be interested to know what anyone thinks about it…
-=chuck=-
I have designed a couple of whistles to be printed on a 3d printer. Included the CAD model so people can change the design.
https://github.com/chucktilbury/whistle
I would be interested to know what anyone thinks about it…
-=chuck=-
Hi Chuck
I have printed V2 of the whistle head. I am new to all of this so I hope you don’t mind me asking a few questions.
First thanks so much for including the FreeCAD files, I have learnt loads from studying those! My prints have a few artefacts at the bottom, where the tube is inserted. I have added a picture. It is not seams as I have those, set to be at the back.
I was wondering what the lines in the Cad files are, they may be causing the issues?
I only have a small printer so I usually make the bodies out of PVC or Aluminium, that is my next step. The head is very clear and loud, which is interesting. A design question, what is the thinking behind the windway being tapered? It is wider at the mouth end. I haven’t seen that before. I also like the flared window.
Thank you again for sharing your files. There are definitely things about the deign that I really like. I will share my experiments as I go!
Cheers from the UK
Martin
Hi Martin,
First thanks so much for including the FreeCAD files, I have learnt loads from studying those!
Awesome. FreeCAD is a great tool and getting better all the time.
The small ridges on the inside are supposed to give a tight enough fit that you can still move for tuning. It looks like maybe your extruder is a little hot at the beginning. What slicer? I am using the Creality slicer which is based on Prusa (ultimately slicr). I can post gcode if you want.
The tapered windway is designed to focus the airflow on the blade. The whistle is loud because of that. A not-tapered windway will give a sweeter and less “dense” sound. Note the position of the blade in relation to the windway. It’s also very important to the way the whistle sounds. Small changes matter a lot.
The flared window also have an effect on the sound. It “opens” the sound and gives it a broader distribution at the cost of being less resistant to wind. Getting rid of the flare will make it a little louder and help playing outdoors.
I love to see what you are dong. ![]()
All the best,
-=c=-
Hi Chuck,
great work. I cloned the repo and looked in the cad files. I get my printer started this evening and give it a try.
I do something similar, but I use Fusion. Another (not only) 3d printed wiz
Your blade has no (V2) or minimal offset to the windway bottom? I used a ratio of 0.3 - 0.4 of the windway height, but my design are ways to breathy.
I’m really excited to see how the whistle plays.
Cheers from Germany
Martin
If memory serves, I used about a .1 mm offset. I didn’t use a ratio, I just moved it around and printed prototypes until it worked.
The airway is tapered, so that changes where the air stream is focused. It’s a little deceptive in the way it looks.
I would love to see what you come up with…
I guess you are printing with a 0.4 mm nozzle, then the edge “comes up” about 0.2 mm.
So not far from this 0.3 ratio.
But seems like I optimized in the wrong direction so far.