Mechanical Tunes

I think the best way to learn is to listen to good players, live or on recordings, and pay attention to their variations. If you listen long enough, you’ll get a sense for what works within the bounds of good taste, and eventually you’ll start hearing variations in your head, which you can work out on your instrument. And then there will come a time when variations start popping out unplanned while you’re playing.

There are lots of great players who excel at variations; John Carty is one who comes to mind, but listen to any great Irish musician and you’ll hear variations. The thing to avoid is extended melodic departures that are thrown in merely to show off one’s technical prowess or creativity. Working within the constraints of the tradition doesn’t stifle creativity at all, and the result is more satisfying.

Thanks Brad!

That’s pretty good advices! I’ll work on that!

Hope I can play with you in Montréal pretty soon!

François

Listening to what more experienced musicians have done is good advice. Also, if you read music, you will find that the many books available have different versions of the same tunes. Many of these versions are actually variations that various players have come up with that have been written down. A lot of these written versions play well against each other as variations.

Learning to play these different versions will help you understand variations, as well as enable you to join different sessions that play their own local version of popular tunes.

djm