I’m still looking for the perfect low D for me. Since I don’t live near any stores (or players) that carry a range of models, I figure the next best option is to ask you all on C&F.
I currently use a Howard, which is wonderful and easy on my lungs, but it clogs a lot and is prone to the odd squawk on d and b. I also use a Kerry (plastic-head model), which has a nice tone but I run out of breath quite quickly.
So, can anyone suggest a low D with low breath requirements comparable to a Howard?
Hi - this is a quote from an email that Mitch, from Oz whistles, recently sent me regarding low D breath requirements. I asked him for his opinion. He’s a really nice guy! Responded rapidly. Here is what he said:
“With breath requirements - for less breath - the Kerry plastic-head, SYN, Howard, Dixon are easiest - then Susato, and MK (medium), then Overton, Reviol, Chieftain, Shaw in that order.”
The only low whisltes I’ve owned are Overton, Chietain, and Shaw, and they were all hard breathers, and in that same order as Mitch lists them in Judith’s reply.
If volume is not a major concern, I would recommend trying a Mack Hoover low D. I have one that takes less air than some of the high D’s I own. Lovely for solo playing.
I just bought a David O’Brien low D, tuneable and find it really easy on the lungs. I do play flute though so that might color my perception a little. It’s an attractive whistle, with nice tone, and a great price. (around $100)
The less backpressure, the faster the air goes through the tube. This means that you need more air if you have to blow less hard. Backpressure means that you you have to blow hard with little air to make a sound. The latter the Overton is known for. But Colin Goldie makes his whistle acoording to your wishes. you only have to call him up or email him.
