I’m sure you’ve heard this question once a week for the last 10 years, but I guess now it’s my turn to ask. But hopefully I can give enough information to help keep this question somewhat answerable.
I’m (obviously by the title) looking for a low D whistle. More specifically, here’s what I’m looking for:
First off, I have small hands and stubby fingers. My handspan is about 8” from thumb tip to pinkie tip, widespread. I’ve got good flexibility in the fingers, so piper’s grip should work for me most of the time, but obviously the “reach” of the whistle is a big factor.
I’m on a limited budget…$200 is top end for what I can manage in the near future.
I play with my son and a friend, so any whistle I get should be tunable.
Finally, I prefer whistles that aren’t “breathy”. As a reference, my favorite whistle is my Sweetheart Pro D…nice clear, clean sound to it.
Backpressure isn’t a huge issue, as long as the whistle doesn’t take tons of air to get through to a good breathing point. Volume isn’t overly worrisome either…in fact, a quieter whistle would work just fine.
So, given all of this, I’m not asking what the “best” whistle is…but am looking for any suggestions on whistles that might meet what I’m hoping to find in a whistle. From what I’ve read, I would think that the Sweetheart Resonance would be wonderful, but out of my range at the moment. Any suggestions here would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!