I have never been a great low D whistle player, but I always had a passion for these instruments.
I owned possibly every brand of low D whistles with the exception of Reyburn, MK and Shaw (really).
Then I stopped for a few years and just started again. So three months ago I bought a Dixon tapered bore plastic Low D. I must say, excellent whistle, much better than the cylindrical plastic whistle that Dixon produced years ago (and that I owned). The low D bottom note is less “fragile”, the sound is more “breathy” (as I like) and overall the playability is excellent.
Then, one month ago, I had the opportunity to purchase at a very discounted price, a Shaw Low D.
Always been intrigued by this instrument. I got it and I love it. Very different from the Dixon, it requires a lot of air, but it has a super breathy sound of its own that I really like.
And here we go to three days ago, when I received in the mail a new Kerry Optima Low D, with a red mouthpiece, which was on sale from Phil Hardy at a very affordable price (less than $100.00 including shipping !).
Let me tell you that among my former whistles of a few years ago my favorites were a Chieftain V3 and a Goldie Overton.
Well, I must say that my new Kerry Optima’s sound reminds me of those two high class whistles.
It is awesome. A joy to play. And quite easy to play indeed, which I understand was a specific goal that Phil Hardy had in mind when he developed the Optima. It is also gorgeous, with that plastic mouthpiece that has a shape very similar to an Overton whistle. Negatives ? Well, who I am to find negatives on such a nice piece of art ?
But if you really push me, I find the low D bottom note just a bit weak (low volume). But I understand that this is the price to pay for having an easy blowing, well intonated, gorgeous sounding low D in both octaves.
I honestly think that it is very difficult today to get any other low D whistle of such a high quality for less than $100.00 (perhaps the MK Kelpie ? but I guess that it is more expensive).
Hope this mini-review will help low D whistle players on a budget, beginners and also everybody who loves the Low D Whistle and is looking to add a great new instrument to his arsenal.
I have a Kerry Optima in E and D and I like mine too! I couldn’t find many posts on C&F but eventually I found some inspiring videos on Phil’s site of Orlaith McAuliffe playing her Optima. Just look to the left hand side on the Kerry whistles and you will find it spelled Orla McAuliffe. Here is the link.
http://www.kerrywhistles.com/movie.php?groupID=37#
As you can see here she is a very accomplished flute player!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=urBS6_p66Mg
Cheers,
Nate
agreed. the optima is great for such an affordable price as well. i use mine for rehearsals and duets, and my MK low D for sessions, concerts and bigger groups. the MK is too loud for a small group, and the Optima is too quiet for a session, but between both, i’ve got my bases covered. plus, they respond and sound a bit different.
Bought one in November 2011 at the very tempting sale price of £59, tried it and knew within 30 seconds it was going back because the top half of the second octave was way sharp. So, yes, I’d seen Orlaith McAuliffe’s videos of the D and Eb (and thought the tone and response of mine stunning over the first octave and a half), but afraid intonation problems of that magnitude suggested a fault of design rather than execution in the E.
I didn’t notice that the second half of the high octave is sharp in my Optima Low D. But I am a very average player.
Next time I will check with a tuner and see.
I’m not talking about the D (which I’ve no reason to suppose compromised), but couldn’t even have been tempted by the E as a gift when the last few were offered as such with D or Eb purchases a month or two after I sent mine back!
Nate,
Orla McAuliffe could play a piece of muffler pipe and make it sound beautiful. The girl is a wonderful musician. ![]()
Cayden