Never played the Dominic, but I think the Optima is an excellent whistle. It took me a while to get used to the hole spacing, not sure why, but once I did I found it easy to play. I like the tone and it’s very lightweight, which is nice. It looks sleek and minimalist too, which I also like. Decent volume. For the price it’s an excellent whistle.
Note I’ve played neither. In general I vote kerry optima, its well known with a good reputation. The JDM could be great and I do have a tendency to go with less known makers. But I’ve also regret my purchase before. But not always haha. So you never know. From listening, it sounds like the JDM is going to be more mellow and less loud. I noticed in both videos, you can hear their breathing really loudly. Which implies the whistle isnt that loud. If it was the mic volume would be turned down more and the breathing would be quieter. But theres more to audio than that so I could be wrong. If you want a more booming low end optima may better. If you want quiet indoor practice JDM could be better.
Phil Hardy would have the definitive response for you. I’ll hazard a guess:
Since the Chieftain/Optima/Busker/Thunderbird/Cobre lines of whistle already have a very high quality tuning slide mechanism, which a buyer would want to remain reliable in function for years, I’d suspect that trying to assure that quality of function sustains itself would have them decide not to put the plastic into the “tuning slide” portion of the whistle, and remain with metal, the plastic probably not as durable under friction over time, as the current materials used for the tuning slide part.
The Optima is an excellent whistle. The videos of it being played are very good and when Orlaith McAuliffe plays an Optima lightning fast and the notes are very well defined and the tone is appealing and very clear and consistent, I’d say the plastic mouthpiece is a total winner, matched perfectly to that pipe design, and the design should not be altered, unless as usual, ongoing R&D discover improvement possibilities.