Getting some O'Riordan whistles!

I"ve had an order with Pat since 2003 and wondered if the day would ever come, due to his health problems. Got a call from him today, yay! My original order was for a concert D and C in blackwood. Anyway, I was thinking about asking Pat if instead of the C, I could get another D, but a different model, such as a Traveler. What are his other models like? I’ll talk to him tomorrow, so any input would be great. Thanks! John.

I have the Travelers in a C/D set, G, and Low D with, hopefully, a Bflat/A set on the way. Although consistent in appearance and workmanship and playability, I wouldn’t characterize them as a group with respect to how they sound, i.e., tone and volume. Generally, they are all clear, round sweet sounding. The D/C is rather loud, but well balanced and not piercing with very pure sound. The G, IMHO, the best of the lot to date, is freakishly sweet or heavenly sounding - really beautiful unique tone and moderate volume. The D is also moderate in volume, pure in sound and perhaps the least exceptional of the lot; it is in three pieces with a turnable bottom joint and I find it relatively easy to play, perhaps due to the small or moderate sized tone holes; others have complained about the reach. I really like them. Hope that helps.

Philo

PS I think Wanderer recently did a review of some Travelers.

Actually, the review was on the concert D with C tube and Traveler D body. He focussed his review on the Concert D though.

As far as asking for a different whistle… Remember you waited 2+ years for your current ones. I don’t think someone would want you to jump in and get their D because you changed your mind and I am pretty sure you would not want to wait even longer for the new tube.

That said, my motto has always been: “Don’t ask, don’t get.” That is how I got my D/C Traveler set in a trade.

Now, if you are REALLY interested in the travelers, maybe we should talk :smiling_imp: (see above)?

One o’ these days I’d like a Traveller or two.
Philo, love your avatar!

Flattery will get you nowhere, my good man and colleague. I’ll be Travelering alone, as it were. :smiley: You too exhibit an astonishing degree of selectivity in your avatar!

Philo

I grew up watching the Jeremy Brett series ( as well as reading the stories), so naturally he’s my favorite Sherlock.

Having played both myself, I’d say stick with the concert series. They feel more substantial in the hand, are a dream to play (like butta!) and have the better tone IMHO. There was something about the traveller series that just didn’t click with me as well.

I grew up watching Basil Rathbone, but Jeremy Brett became my favorite Sherlock as well. Great minds…

Philo