In my ongoing quest to acquire every cheapie, I just got a Clare two-piece. I haven’t really heard much about them here, so I wasn’t quite sure what to expect, but it is awesome.
IMO it is the best untweaked cheapie I have played (not that I have played them all yet.)
Just wondering why I haven’t heard more about them when they are this good.
I have a 2 piece Clare. I like the sound. I only have one fussy thing to mention. After taking it apart and putting it back together so many times, the two pieces didn’t seal well and it got all chiffy. I used teflon tape for awhile but once you take the whistle apart, the teflon tape wasn’t so reusable again. Always having access to teflon tape didn’t work out either. I then got some latex tubing to cover the joint. That sealed things well but it’s a bit difficult to get on the first time and then to roll back to separate the pieces. The joint is a bit loose and the latex keeps it snug but the whistle looks a bit bent.
I once bought a single piece clare whistle from The Whistle Shop maybe 4 years ago, and I didn’t think very highly of it, it was playable, but I liked my Gens and Feadogs more. That’s my only experience with a Clare whistle.
I have a two piece Clare - I believe it was referred to as the “Eagle” model - splits pretty far down the tube (about one-third-two thirds) and has a really light lime green mouthpiece. It’s a pretty nice whistle but I have other favorite cheapies that I’d stack up against any whistles in the same respective keys.
The now legendary and no longer made Walton Golden Tone C - I have one with a yellow and one with a green mouthpiece - both extraordinary. I liked one that I tried so much I called Walton (upstate NY, I believe) and asked them to send me all that they had left - 4 whistles; I gifted 2 and kept 2. That was some years ago.
Generation Bflat - I have one nickel blue top and one brass red top and both are also great whistles.
My old Clarke D and C whistles are also really good as is my very old Susato D/C/Bflat set.
I appreciate these threads because it gets me to go through my jars of old cheapies, which is amazing fun.
Well, I like Clarke original’s sound a little more, but it isn’t all that fun to play. I have to breath twice as much as with any other whistle I own.
So, next in my quest might have to be a tweaked Clarke so it takes less air.