Whistle form

Whistle
1

As a self-taught whistler, I’ve always wondered about the best way to hold the whistle. I have a picture of Willie Clancy playing where he’s holding it almost horizontally; this makes sense inasmuch as it would put the weight almost entirely on the thumbs, leaving the other fingers free to float lightly above the instrument. However, I’ve also seen a picture of Mary Bergin holding it much more vertically. Also, what about the right pinkie: resting on the whistle or held away? I’ve been experimenting with both and find virtues in each. What do you think, fellow whistlers?
Jon Michaels

[ This Message was edited by: Jon-M on 2002-04-03 13:13 ]

2

3

I don’t think there’s any right or wrong way, inasmuch as whatever is comfortable for you is how you should play.

4

I agree with “TelegramSam.”

I tend to blow out of the side of my mouth, with the whistle to my right about 10 degrees. I can hear myself better and the right hand is more comfortable on the barrel. But a friend I play with holds his whistle as perpendicular as possible.

Beside, after three or four pints of Guinnes, you’re not going to even know what position you’re in–and you won’t care. :-0