The Irish tradition is that melody instruments always play melody. They might also harmonize with the melody, ie double-stops on a fiddle, or the drone of pipes, but they are playing the melody, too. This is explicitly written into the fleadh duo/trio rules, for instance.
How often this tradition is broken in Ireland I can’t tell you. Obviously it is broken pretty regularly at our local session, as I mention above.
elaborating a bit (from the Pat Mitchell article mentioned earlier):
As I understand it, Irish traditional dance music is a single line music. In other words, it consists
only of structured melody as opposed to western European art music which is based on melody
(the theme) plus harmonic textures and progressions. For many composers the theme plays
quite a small role with the major focus being the harmonic content.
Single line music appears to have been the norm in Europe up to the Middle Ages. Apart from
China, single line music prevailed in art and folk musics in many countries around the world.
Since the beginning of the 19th century, there has been pressure on many cultures, including that
of Ireland, to drop their native music or convert it to something resembling western art music.
Much of this pressure may well have a social and economic rather than an artistic basis.
Western Europe has led the world since Renaissance times in education and economic
development. (In the context of the discussion, I would regard North America as an offshoot of
Europe.) It is easy to see how people playing ‘other’ music could perceive it as backward and
embrace the more ‘advanced’ music. If the musicians had stopped to take note of the extent to
which the exploitation of their country’s people and resources played a major part in that
perceived wealth and development, then maybe they would not have been so easily influenced.
Daniel Corkery, in ‘The Hidden Ireland’, referring specifically to literature and decrying the way
many Irish people looked down on their language and heritage, summed up the situation:
“The first article in an Ascendancy’s creed is, and has always been, that the natives are a
lesser breed, and that anything that is theirs (except their land and their gold!) is
therefore of little value. If they have had a language and literature, it cannot have been a
civilised language, cannot have been anything but a patois used by the hillmen among
themselves; and as for their literature, the less said about it the better. In the course of
time the natives become tainted with these doctrines; and cry approval when the
untruths of the Ascendancy are echoed from some distant place, as if at last a fair
judgement has been pronounced, not recollecting that the Ascendancy have had for
hundreds of years possession of the ear of the world and have not failed to fill it with
such opinions as were opportune.”
Fortunately, single line music of great melodic and rhythmic subtlety and complexity is still
played in India and Turkey.
While Irish traditional dance music may not have reached the level of development of Indian
classical music, when played well it is a multi-layered music full of subtlety and variation. The
scale of Irish traditional dance music is very different to that of western European art music or
other harmony-based music such as jazz. Both of these musics tend to move in broad harmonic
sweeps. By comparison, Irish traditional dance music changes on a microscopic scale with, for
instance, small variations in the timing of a grace note played at or near the end of a note greatly
altering the effect of the graced note for those who can perceive it. My own personal experience
suggests that those brought up only on harmonic music cannot actually hear all that is going on
in good Irish traditional dance music performance unless they spend a great deal of time
educating their ear.
I think this is one of those myths of Irish music. Melodic instruments play the melody, absolutely, but the tradition also allows them to back themselves with some harmony. (Which isn’t to say that harmony is needed! But it is sometimes nice to have a bit.)
I mean, a full set of pipes is designed to be able to play, what, four different notes at once, right?
hehe. Myth? Breandan Breathnach was an historian and tune-collector, and his book on the tradition was written after living alongside and playing with the musicians who were the tradition! Myth indeed.
He also wrote:
“Group playing is another modern fashion to be avoided.
Traditional playing, it must be remembered, is of its very nature
a personal expression, and the restraint demanded in playing in a
band or other ensemble kills the spirit which animates it.”
Pipes (and harp) were played solo. There’s a heeyoooge difference between a solo piper switching on his drones and (very) occasionally tapping the regulators, or a solo harpist (or fiddler for that matter) double-stopping, and some bloke in group of 30 musos sat in a circle in a pub noodling out “counter-point” or “harmony” (especially when he can’t be 'arrised to learn).
He was of course talking about the tradition, a tradition he lived as a part of, and he wrote the book a long time ago. Back when the tradition consisted of musos (3 or 4 at most) played together in a house or maybe a pub. Long before the Chieftains took the world by storm, long before the likes of Dervish and Lunasa et al. Although, of course, it was in that very tradition which today’s stellar performers got their grounding.
Of course, traditions change and his book wasn’t meant to be cast in stone. He also lamented back in the 70’s about the introduction of guitar into the music:
“We are now informed in all seriousness that
the lighter commercial ballad personified by the guitar as the
basic accompaniment instrument must be regarded as coming within the
definition of Irish traditional music.”
And well, it’s accepted today.
Straying away from unison into the realms of “harmonising” and “counter-point” is definitely a trigger for the “pure-drop police” I reckon. Here they come!
If he was honestly trying to say what you’re saying he was trying to say, then damned straight, myth.
Pipes (and harp) were played solo. There’s a heeyoooge difference between a solo piper switching on his drones and (very) occasionally tapping the regulators, or a solo harpist (or fiddler for that matter) double-stopping, and some bloke in group of 30 musos sat in a circle in a pub noodling out “counter-point” or “harmony” (especially when he can’t be 'arrised to learn).
Yeah, and if you’d spend 30 seconds actually trying to read what I’ve written, you’ll see I’m agreeing with you re “counter-point” and “noodling”. Everyone who can plays the melody (except possibly guitar and piano, which aren’t that traditional anyway).
But you can’t sit there and say chanters plus drones plus regulators means there’s no harmony in Irish traditional music. That’s just daft. The tradition most certainly includes people who play the melody playing notes (not in unison) to back themselves up. It is utterly common in older traditional players who play instruments capable of it.
Oy, if you’ve a problem with what Breandan Breathnach wrote, take it up with him!
And if you quote a quote, at least give credit where it’s due. It was Breandan Breathnach who wrote “Irish folk music is essentially melodic. It uses no form of harmonic accompaniment or modulation…” not me.
And if you’d spend 30 seconds actually trying to read what I’ve written, you’ll see I’m agreeing with you that there’s a big difference between double-stopping and the drones/regulators, and the commonly accepted understanding of the word “harmony” (in which the melody line is accompanied by other lines not in unison, and accompanying chords).
Ummm… creating accompanying chords is exactly what double-stopping and regulators do. That is harmony, plain and simple: “Harmony - is when two or more different musical sounds occur at the same time.”
Fancy counter-point is a very specialized subset of harmony.
I’m all little disappointed that the concertina wasnt mentionned as an instrument that can wreak havoc with chords, you can also play many notes simultaneously with it Also don’t forget the box with it’s evil “chord” buttons.
The session I go to is explicitly a beginner’s session, and despite this there are few tunes I know/can keep up with. So I spend most of the time listening. The other people in the session go out of their way to be welcoming to new musicians and usually ask me to start a tune when they notice I haven’t played for a long time. That’s really nice and I appreciate it a lot, but I really like listening. It’s an extremely valuable time for me to just sit and tap my foot and follow the music in my head. So often going to sessions seems to be equated with playing. But there’s a lot to be learned just from hearing others play, I think.
What about the piano playing you get behind old recordings and more than a few modern ones? Isn’t this harmony?
I saw Noel Hill recently and he had an electric piano backing him and Alec Finn wasn’t just following the melody line a lot of the time.
Yes, absolutely. Though I’d think you’d get an argument that this was non-traditional when it first appeared on recordings back in the 1920s.
For whatever reason (probably has something to do with being much less traditional, and good at playing chords), guitar and piano aren’t “required” to play the melody, even though they’re both quite capable of playing the melody, and sometimes will play it. However, neither of them would traditionally play counter-point, either – just some sort of chords to provide harmony.
I think we could endlessly wax pedantic on what is considered harmony in traditional music (by the way, “pedantic” is officially my word of the month for March). Harmony is probably here to stay though hopefully there are enough traditionalists to keep the invasion to a moderate level. Some I like but find a lot of it over-the-top. If I had to choose I’d take none over any in interest of keeping the tunes and songs alive instead of turning into symphonic movements.
I think the quotes from Messrs Mitchell and Breathnach provide excellent counterpoint (oops, harmony pun ) to a lot of the “Nouveau Trad” ensembles.
Well, not being a flute player I’m not sure what the feeling about spelling is in this neck of the woods . I myself would not consider it pedantic in the least to wonder about a misspelled (I hope I spelled that right, Steve Shaw caught me on that one—yeah, I know, I could look it up) word. I think it’s a typo that no one noticed.