I inherited a wooden Bb fife (stamped “Geo. Cloos Crosby”) from my wife’s grandfather.It’s about 17" long with 2" silver ferrules at the ends. I don’t know what kind of wood it is. Not the most forgiving embouchure; but I’m able to get two clear octaves (the cat is anything but impressed!). It’s an interesting diversion from my D flute.
Now that I have been playing it, I see moisture in the embouchure hole. The bore is 10 mm at the end (can’t tell if it is a conical bore) and 35.5 cm long internally. So how do I swab it out without getting a swab stuck inside? Or do I need to?
Your fife is probably 100 years old… very nice inheritance and a great collector piece.
You definitely need to swab it out after playing. I couldn’t find a swab that was suitable for my fife, so I made one. I bought the thinnest piece of dowel I could find at Home Depot, cut it to 2" longer than the fife, and then glued a small piece of soft sponge to the tip. I trimmed the sponge with a scissors, nothing fancy and certainly not perfectly cylindrical, but slightly larger than the inside diameter of the bore. That way when I insert it, it touches all around. Then I push it gently to the cork and then back out again with slow spiral. I made a second one that I use for oiling the inside of the fife. Just like your flute, the fife needs oiling every 5-10 hours of play. I also use a cotton bud (Q-tip) to oil the inside of the embouchure hole and finger holes of my fife.
Flutes don’t need oiling every 5-10 hrs. Consider that makers of $14k wood Boehm flutes, such as Chris Abell, recommend oiling only once per year, during in-shop service. Consider also that flutes in that price range are geared towards professional players who are likely to be playing hundreds of hours between oilings. Truth is, it’s debatable whether flutes even “need” oiling at all, unless severely neglected. Many players rarely oil their flutes and wooden flute makers’ recommendations vary widely, even when the materials and processes used to make the instruments are essentially the same.
In my repair/service/restoration work I saw no benefit to oiling other than cosmetic except in the relatively rare cases of really poorly cared for instruments. That being the case I stopped oiling my flutes 15-20 years ago with no (perceivable) ill effects. There have been several benefits, including time saved, and more consistent tone and response from my instruments. Also, for woods like boxwood, joints that swell too tightly to be separated unswell (is that even a word?) more quickly than when I have regularly oiled those instruments.
I’ve no significant experience with Fifes, so I cannot comment on them and leave that to any fife makers and/or highly experienced players to speak about fife specific care and maintenance. Perhaps there is something about fifes, softer more porous woods maybe, that would make oiling more often necessary. Hopefully Walt and/or David M. will comment.
Certainly it’s prudent to follow any instrument maker’s specific care recommendations, if you know them, including those on oiling.
One final caveat to my comments above: If you are going to play a flute (or whistle) that hasn’t been played in years, and/or is coming from an extremely dry region, oiling prior to playing the first time “might” help prevent it from cracking BUT, the best method to prevent a very dry instrument from cracking upon first play is to slowly bring the wood back to a proper humidity level through a slow humidification process over a period of days prior to playing. Oil alone won’t restore the wood’s moisture content, it will only slow the absorption of moisture into some areas of the wood.
I think it depends on the wood the flute or fife is made of. The oil (usually linseed) might take weeks or more to harden but should gum within a day or two maybe ? There is polymerised linseed which is all natural which dries faster it seems, or citrus thinner also is supposed to help drying ? When a flute is made it is usually soaked or given mutiple coats of oil, the depth achieved will depend on the porosity of the wood amongst other. Sanding down often oiled fruitwood it seemed under a mm. The outside surface degrades over time which is probably when a light coat of oil is needed ? Chris Abell for example says to oil his whistles occasionally ? Personally I just go by texture of the wood being dryish.
Aside from that, there are great differences in absorption properties of wood. Blackwood is the most resistant according to a chart here
And I expect that counts for its ability to absorb oil also. So no point oiling it often probably? Another chart of various wood types elsewhere showed wood released water when in air twice as fast as it absorbed it when immersed [but still takes a long time to release all all all the water absorbed, hence a build up to a stable level in a flute]..whatever that adds up to.
Finally, I find a regular wipe of the outside of a flute with oil after playing helps keep it clean… on dark wood you would not notice staining though…and eventually gives the wood a beautiful surface.
So, well my advice if you don’t know the wood is to wipe the inside with oil properly every month or two… at least twice a year … depending … let that sit for half an hour before wiping clean, and then give it as much time to dry as possible… overnight if possible or longer. It should absorb better if the flute is dryish before oiling also.
Probably others have other recommendations though.
Thanks, everyone, for your observations and suggestions. It has been years (and I do mean years) since this instrument was played. So I am taking it easy–like breaking it in. Maybe I should say breaking us both in. I have only been playing flute for a little over two years and I don’t intend to strain the embouchure, either. The fife has come this far with only some dents in the end of the ferrules. I’m going to try to keep it that way.