I’ve been pondering on purchasing one of these, because I want to buy a whistle above 30$ (minimum for international shipping) to a max of 50$ (budget) Canadian. I frankly don’t know anything about these whistles, so any tonal qualities or even audio/video clips would be greatly appreciated. Are there any other whistles in this price range? And what is the difference between a small and very small bore?
Buy an Impempe, a beautifully made alloy whistle from Ian Turnbull, south Africa: impempe.mysite.wanadoo-members.co.uk. There’s also a review on the C&F. Its sound is full and complex, a very easy blower, also in the higher octave, and well in tune. It’s supposed to be a soft whistle. I have 4 Impempes: a Bb and a C that are a bit soft and must be underblown. I also have an F and a D that are quite loud. Thing is that the sound is so very focused it can be heard from quite a distance. So the magic is that it’s sometimes soft and loud at the same time. It’s a whistle for $40,- worth more than twice the price. I recommend it to you.
I personally like susatos, although you’ll get some mixed reactions on this board. They’re loud, well-tuned, and fairly even in my experience.
The very small bore is a quieter whistle than the regular small bore. I don’t have a VSB, but that’s what I’ve heard.
Another whistle to consider in this price range (and lower) is the Dixon polymer. I have one, and it’s my favorite whistle once you get the hang of it. They’re tunable (like the Kildare) and have a very clear tone. They’re loud enough to hold up in a session without totally overpowering. I got mine for about $25 (USA) without shipping. Dixon whistles in general have an even quality to them that I like very much, so I guess that’s another brand to consider. ![]()
I live in Canada, so some stuff might be harder to get for me. I’m checking out the ones you guys said now.
I like Susatos a lot as well. Get the C body as well if you can.
The small bore has a much richer tone than the VSB but the top of the second octave is quite loud. It is nice to have both.
Here are some Susato videos,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9DLP4PobwY&mode=related&search=Susato%20"A"%20whistle
Here is a video of a Susato C
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9DLP4PobwY&mode=related&search=Susato%20"A"%20whistle
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9DLP4PobwY&mode=related&search=Susato%20"A"%20whistle
Does the C body have to be in the key of C? Or is it just named that?
Here are a couple Dixon polymer whistles on eBay with a ‘Buy It Now’, and they are in Canada.
With the two-peice Susato Kildare whistles you can save a lot of money by buying one head and several bodies. If you remove the head from the D whistle and put it on the C body you have a C whistle, i.e. a whistle in the key of C. Some other whistle makers offer the same option.
The C Susato is very nice IMHO.
And a Dixon whistle
I have a Susato Kildare VSB in D and is my best whistle. It’s louder than my other whistles, but it sounds fantastic.
I love my sussato, (the holes are big and evenly spaced, its tunable, it fits nicley in my hand, the fipple fits nicely in my mouth) until I blow into it. then its over. very loud and piercing, second octave must be overblown. its the only trad instrament that makes my ears ring after playing it. I recomend you make your own, you can make it how you want it. go to http://guido.gonzato.googlepages.com/whistle.html to figure out how.
I love my sussato, (the holes are big and evenly spaced, its tunable, it fits nicley in my hand, the fipple fits nicely in my mouth) UNTIL I BLOW INTO IT. then its over. very loud and piercing, second octave must be overblown. its the only trad instrament that makes my ears ring after playing it. I recomend you make your own, you can make it how you want it. go to http://guido.gonzato.googlepages.com/whistle.html to figure out how.
Sh*t dude… thats harsh. ![]()
Here I thought I was tough on them.
Now I respect the Susato guys but I don’t think the product is as consistent as advertised. I have the privilege to play a number different ones now. The first one I had the chance to play had some issues. They were confirmed by a respected Susato lover.
I’ve played others and found them enjoyable…the keys below D.
I’ve made some tweeks to my D and I have learned to control it… but I still do not enjoy it.
We all change our minds about our tools as we improve and gain experience. So who knows.
Currently… my lack of years playing being a guide… I can’t recommend a Susato as a first or second instrument.
Others feel free to disagree… as it will be.
Oh, bats… I hope you like bats.
My suggestion for a whistle at 30$ for your level.
Dixon Trad.
Its not to hard but its not too easy to control either. A good intermediate whistle perhaps. Its also not too loud and you can play without loosing spouses, house mates or neighbors. ![]()
I have a Dixon trad but no Susato.
I sometimes play along with womeone who’s got a Susato though. It sounds MUCH louder that my Dixon.
I would make the same comparison with a Phil Bleazy and a Copeland, but those might not be in your budget.
Pascal.
I’m coming from a Generation, so how would they compare in tone/volume/and air requirement?
Which, Susato or Dixon?
Either or both
It may be good for you use the search function as you will find a lot has been written already about both Susatos and Dixons. Listening to the clips will also help.
Good luck in finding a suitable whistle.
Susato Kildare S series:
Tone: more woody/nasal than a gen
Volume: quite a bit louder than a gen
Air req: both air volume and backpressure are similar to most gens - keep in mind that there’s a lot of variation in gens and that there’s a lot you can do with a Susato in this department - have a look at MTGuru’s tweek thread and others.
Dixon whistles.
The main choices will be either the older poly ones and the newer “trad” style ones:
Poly:
tone: softer than a gen
quiter
a little less air req but same backpressure
Trad:
Similar to a gen in most ways - smoother between the octaves and a slightly harder tone.
Gotta say though - every kind of whistle will have some variance, one to the next. Some brands more than others. It’s the nature of the beast.
Hope this helps!
Thanks, it helped quite a bit.