I’m having reservations about a whistle I received for Christmas and would like to know if others are experiencing the same thing and have been reluctant to do anything about it. The whistle in question is purpleheart and arrived new and in need of fine sanding and polishing. There is roughness of the fipple plug and the tip of the mouthpiece (which has unfinished endgrain) when I’m playing and the bore snags fibers from the swab when oiling or drying. Can’t get a finger inside to know how smooth the bore is, but as the grain hasn’t been well-polished on the outside, it could follow that the inside is the same.
As for the way the whistle plays, others besides me have commented that it is unpleasantly hard to blow and the tone obtained isn’t worth the effort. I have oiled it several times but that didn’t solve the problem.
The local supplier said that complaints about this maker’s whistles are rare and I don’t to injure a maker’s reputation by giving names at this point. On the other hand, another Chiffer told me that rough finish is typical of this maker’s whistles (and also where to I could obtain the 8 grades of sanding cloth to fix it) so now I’m wondering if this is a “king has no clothes” situation and most folks are so happy to have the waiting over that they won’t complain about the fact that the whistle they received is less than stellar. I also wonder if whistles sold in the maker’s home country have a better finish than those sent to the U.S.?
When I asked about a remedy the supplier said: “Yeah, the fipple plug should not be rough enough to distract you. Naturally it’s not gonna be like glass or anything, but I don’t see why you should need to sand it. …
I’m afraid, short of sending it back to ****** for sanding, there’s
little we can do. Of course you take it’s life in your own hands by
sanding, yourself - but otherwise you could be without it for weeks, and
risk further damage in shipping. With every batch we further discuss the
instrument with the maker. Thank you for all your input. Let me know if
there’s anything else we can do.” THAT was encouraging.
Maybe the lesson to be learned here is that I should not have gone with anyone other than the great local whistle makers who make the effort to keep themselves visible and informed as to what their customers expect and don’t insulate themselves behind their foreign distributors.
Any thoughts?
