How to finger "B"?

Brand-spanking newbee, so if this sounds stupid, cut me some slack. Oh, and I can’t read music for squat. :smiley:

Just for grins, I’d like to try and play “Ripple” by the Grateful Dead. The first note is a “B”…two down from “D”.

How in the world would you finger that note?

Ummm… L1 (i.e. XOOOOO)

Pat

Hi VAC, welcome to Chiff & Fipple, and the exciting world of whistles. :thumbsup:

Pat,

No, that B is too high…I need the B on the next octave down (if it’s even possible).

Patrick

Nope, not possible. You have to a) Play any notes below low D up an octave; or b) Transpose the song to a different key; or c) Use a whistle in a different key.

That’s the answer I was afraid of! :laughing:

Thanks for y’alls help!

Hi VA - welcome to the exclusive ultra-norm-neuveaux werld of whistledom :wink:

hmmm .. Ripple is essentially in G. That can be played on a D whistle, but on a normal high D it will come out shriekingly high .. perhapse it will have its charm if played with confidence :wink: Otherwise, you can use a low D whistle or an alto G whistle.

Your notes will be a selection of: G A B C D E and F#
So on a low D - that’s all the normal notes except C - which is played OXX OOO in the first octave or OXO OOO in the second octave (or D00 000 with the top hole half covered).

On a G whistle it’s all the normal notes. You would start on XXX XOO.

Great song. I hope you get it down!

Thanks, Mitch.

I usually cough when there’s a note I can’t play…

Yes if the lowest note in the tune is B and the tune is in G major it might work best on a Low G whistle.

But it’s very common for trad Irish tunes in G to have a Low B or two, and these tunes are nearly always played on a D whistle. Just those Low B’s are played an octave up, the rest of the tune stays in the usual octave.

A common example is the reel The Banshee which starts

GGGD EDBD | GGGB d_Bd | etc

The B in the first bar is played low on accordion, fiddle, tenor banjo, etc but high on flute, whistle, and uilleann pipes. Nobody even notices.