Flute Beginner Questions

I’m a beginner on the Irish flute, so I have quite a few questions, especially about embouchure.

This is my video: https://drive.google.com/file/d/16wnqSUF9aOseTae8vy8iabaKJKiwcp6w/view?usp=share_link

Q1: Someone told me that I should adjust my embouchure for every note, gradually tighten my lips, and direct the air stream more horizontally across the embouchure hole as the notes get higher. But how does that work when playing fast tunes? Do I still need to adjust my embouchure for every note, or is it enough to adjust it when changing registers? Also, do I actually need to adjust the embouchure, or should I just increase the air speed?

Q2: Whenever I try to produce a really strong, powerful sound, my intonation tends to get worse. Is that normal?

Q3: If I want to change my tone color (timbre), should I slightly turn my head, adjust the angle of the flute, or change my embouchure?

Q4: Are there any comprehensive Irish flute tutorials or learning resources you would recommend?

Thanks in advance for any advice or suggestions! I really appreciate your help!

1 Like

I still think of myself as a beginner, but I’ve been playing 2-3 years. So maybe I have graduated to intermediate. On the one hand that means I’m no expert. On the other hand, I’ve been out there trying to figure out these same sorts of questions. The embouchure takes a while – like at least a year if not more – to develop. I would focus less on things like adjusting for every note and more about sound. Let the sound be your guide. If it is strong, rich, resonant…or some other descriptors…but most importantly sounds good to you, then you are on the right track. Here is a tone exercise you could try that was passed along to me:

Start on the note B and work your way down to D.

Play the note B for approx 3-4 seconds, rest for 3-4 seconds (keeping the flute in place) and repeat. Repeat this for one minute.

Repeat for each note B, A, G, F, E, D.

Concentrate on the following:

  • Position of bottom lip…covering approx 1/3rd of the embouchure hole

  • Flute being held securely against chin…needs positive pressure

  • Downward direction of air…aim for 98.3% into flute

  • Small space between lips…airstream like a laser beam

  • Air Pressure being maintained by diaphragm pressure, not the cheeks

  • Steady exhale right across the 4 seconds

  • Flute being held parallel to lips

  • Consistent Quality of note being produced

2 Likes

How do you determine how much air goes into the flute?

If it is strong, rich, resonant…or some other descriptors…but most importantly sounds good to you, then you are on the right track

Are there any general principles to follow? For example, should I prioritize accurate intonation over achieving a strong, rich, resonant sound? For some notes, like A, I can only achieve accurate intonation by playing more softly, which makes the sound weaker.

Hi Nekroz! Your embouchure will be an ever evolving journey. You already have some good advice above, so I’ll just add a bit that I think wasn’t addressed.

First and foremost…you will eventually find you adjust for notes automatically. Just try for a good tone when you practice. Use what advice already given works, and you will find that if you have a good flute…you’ll start doing the micro adjustments without even thinking about it. Also, all flutes are a tad different. On many antiques, you have to lip down A and Bs but lip up other notes like F#. More modern flutes tend to be more in tune across the board, but there are always micro-adjustments you will come to make automatically. I believe aiming for a nice tone is the key. Also, if you play with others…listen! I’m often adjusting my playing by listening to others…remember, if playing with accordions or concertinas they are always what you play to since they can’t tune. You can also get many phone app tuners to play a tone for you like a D as a drone…that can be helpful to play along with. Definitely try not to stress about it…it takes serious time to get your lip up to speed!

If you try to blow harder but your embouchure isn’t well developed, it will not sound as good. Just keep playing and you’ll eventually be able to hit the notes with a hard edge when you want to with good tone.

As for how to tell if you are blowing down into the hole, you can often tell if there is a lot of condensation on the edge of the headjoint across from the embouchure hole. That said, at first it’s hard to know. Again, don’t stress too much about it - with time and practice, you’ll find yourself blowing more into the hole than across it like a soda bottle. It’s the blowing down into the flute that gives it that harder, traditional style sound. Rolling in the headjoint so the embouchure is about centered to the middle of the tone holes edge that is closest to you is one way to easily ensure you are blowing more into the flute than across the flute. Dang…tried to find a good online image of what I mean, but basically don’t line up the embouchure hole with the tone holes…roll that headjoint a bit more in towards your chin.

Don’t always try to play loud and hard. Try playing quietly with good intonation as well. Quite a few years back in my career, I had to travel a lot and would take my flute to practice at the hotel (I was newer to flute at the time). I personally found practicing quietly with good intonation really helped my playing overall.

Finally, realize this is a long journey, but one I find well worth it. Not just your lips can change your sound but how you hold the flute. If you tense up, you may be changing the angle of the embouchure in relation to your lips, changing your lips, or changing the angle of the whole flute so you can’t cover all the holes completely. Flute is a unique critter. I often look enviously at those damnable string players with their frets and all and think…you all have it sooo easy…and don’t even get me started on the lazy box players! LOL. Just kidding, kind of.

Eric

2 Likes

Seek out flute teacher. Seriously, that will save you a lot of frustration and speed up your learning immensely. Try one lesson a month, to reset your learning.

It might even be a regular, silver flute teacher. But note that the desired tone qualities and techniques are not always the same. Silver flutes are usually played with a pure tone and blowing more across the embouchure; ITM expects darker & rougher tone, which comes from blowing more downward.

Start with the G note and work down and up from there.

@JOBDC @tstermitz @Jayhawk I’ve uploaded a video. Could you help me identify the problems? https://drive.google.com/file/d/16wnqSUF9aOseTae8vy8iabaKJKiwcp6w/view?usp=share_link

For a beginner that’s a nice little clip. How long have you been playing?

I can’t see your face so no comment on embouchure angle, but I think you just need to keep playing and practicing.

Tom is right about lessons…they are invaluable, but I think you may be being harder on yourself than you need to be. I played sax for a long time (in a couple of jazz bands over the years), some banjo, mandolin and a bit of accordion. I find the flute to be a tougher instrument to master. Just keep practicing.

Eric

I’ve been playing a keyless flute for about a year, but I’ve mostly been relying on my experience with other types of flutes. If I’m on the right track, I’ll keep practicing. Thanks!

Definitely sounds like you are on the right track to me! There are lots of online tutorials and books that you could sample but I have found lessons, whether in person or over zoom, to be the most effective in improving my playing. If you have a local or regional Comhaltas branch you could check their website for teachers. Even if you don’t have a local branch, you could look at the websites for other regions to see if there are teachers offering online lessons.

It’s definitely worth a look at the Whistletutor on YouTube. He’s got some great content on flute and whistle.