i know this has probably been explained before in here, but i searched back and couldn’t find anything, probably missed it. What is the difference between the two, and which one is more preferable? thanks. i have looked at the his website, and it was a little helpful, but didnt explain the whole thing.
Hi
you also have to take into consideration from the e-mail I recieved yesterday that Phil has reworked the chieftain new style and come up with a new model called the V3, he says he has fallen in love with the sound but then he makes them so I would expect that, he has promised to put some soundfile reviews up soon, the design as far as I can tell is a sort of hybrid of the songbird and the Chieftain low D.
SORRY NOT MUCH HELP REGARDING YOUR QUESTION
sponge
![]()
i saw some pictures of the V3, it was beautiful. Phil Hardy said he absolutely loves it.
There is now a sound clip up on his site in the profiles section
sponge ![]()
The windway and tone hole on the new V3 looks kinda like an MK don’t ya think? ![]()
So it’s a hybrid in more ways than one? ![]()
Very nice looking whistle. Think I might have to get my hands on one of these.
I have played the Songbird, Chieftain OS, a newer but not NR Chieftain, and a KerryPro.
Songbird: slightly quieter, slightly more flute-like.
Chieftain: more whistle-like, louder than Songbird.
KerryPro: “deeper” sounding, whistle-like, highest quality (in my opinion).
At the moment, I like all three about the same. I currently own a Chieftain and KerryPro. The KerryPro is definitely fancier and looks like a Overton.
-Casey