Hello Whistlers,
Any Comparative opinions between a Burke Pro Low-D in aluminum and an aluminum Overton Big-hole Low-D?
I’ve been playing a Dixon Low-D for several months and want something with more volume. The dixon is too quiet on the low-end.
Hi: Although I do not have, nor have I played, an Overton, I do own both Dixon and Burke Al Pro Low D’s
I think the recommendation to begin with the Dixon Low D is very good advice. For the price, the sound and reach are good. It is reliable in both octaves and you can get a good idea whether low D’s suit you by playing one for awhile (and Low D’s DO take a little getting used to).
I chose the Burke for my high-end Low D and have been very pleased with the quality and feel of the instrument (not too heavy). The brushed aluminum is attractive, it never clogs, and is capable of playing the low octave whisper soft, or loudly without cracking into the second octave. I appreciate the feel of the Burke’s mouthpiece in comparison to the Dixon’s. I am still learning to harness its energy without cracking the occasional high note, but its low register is absolutely velvety.
That said, I would LOVE to have an Overton BHD (wipes away a tear ~ I can’t believe all these deals come and go when I turn my back on the computer for a few hours) SO — ANYONE out there with a yen to sell theirs PLEASE contact me! 
(mgvollmert@hotmail.com)
Mary
I used to own a Burke AlPro low D, and have played a friend’s Overton low D.
They are very different beasts. The Burke has a very mellow and quiet tone, almost tenor recorder-like. It is also quite easy to play. The Overton sounds more like a whistle, requires more wind to play, and is fairly loud. Both are wonderful instruments.
Cheers,
Michael