I disagree with this advice. You should learn how to play that “rickity-tickity nonsense” and then be in a position where you can choose when in a tune to play it, or not. Not playing tight triplets and backstitches because you don’t think they fit a particular tune, your mood/style, whatever, is one thing. Not playing them because you never learned how is different. And until you become relaxed and proficient at playing certain articulations/ornaments, they won’t “feel right.” I personally think the tight fingering work is one of the things that distinguishes the sound of the uilleann pipes from that of other instruments. You don’t have to go totally wild with it like Patsy Touhey, but you should know how to play it.
I rather like the title, ‘The CHasR from Aisle 6.’ Yes, 30 months (well, I did take a 3day Boot camp initially with Benedict many years ago, before I got frustrated and put them aside!). Thank you… I know I sound more like a flute/whistle player at the moment, but I am working on changing that up.
Arbo
mm -hmm 
my salient point being, that tight piping (or as its been called, rickety-tickety-bada-blingidy-boom piping
) is but one spice among many at the players disposal. I think there s too much emphasis on it, to the scale of making UP instruction as rigid as GHB methodology. Its just not the goalpost, from my perspective. Too much tight & ya might as well play Northumbrian. Too little & ya might as well play Biniou. Give me a good old mordent, nachschlag, variable depth vibrato, or trill any day.
But take silver spears advice anyway..., he;s an expert player in touch with the pure drop.
Yes! that is good advice, and its a bit inconsiderate to advise someone to not bother with an important part of Uilleann piping just because you don’t like it. IMHO.
RORY
whatevs ![]()
Are you a regular on the Gerry springer show.
RORY
darnit.
busted!
seriously Rory, one of the main draws of the uilleann chanter, musically speaking, is sheer variety of sounds and substantial freedom available from it. If the big guys start hammering beg & int players on “TIGHT TIGHT TIGHT !!!” as the be-all-&-end-all of Uilleann expression, then we all might as well just strap on kilts & do parades. Let peeps get their open-style rocks off until they get bored with it, I say. Then pepper in the triplets, staccato runs, full stops, etc, etc. Roads to Rome & all that. Whatevs. ![]()
& as someone we all know & (sometimes) loved oft said: “play what the feck ye want” ![]()
Tight playing is the result of closure. And yet, closure does not imply tight playing. C’est absurd!
“But take silver spears advice anyway…, he;s an expert player in touch with the pure drop.” ChasR.
Silver Spear is a lady not a gent - Good piping Arbo ![]()
“Expert” might be exaggerating things a bit. ![]()
I think it is a nice idea to post videos of ourselves playing, and get advice from others! ![]()
Thanks all for the feedback. I would certainly like to be able to execute the tight piping tradition, and I AM working on it slowly with the guidance of a teacher. For the tune recorded, I have had no examples of what to do with respect to tight piping, nor had I any suggestions of where to include examples. So, I tried what was in my grasp which included a couple of variations. I could most certainly work on E crans, and on E rolls as a variation, a bcd triplet getting to the B part, or in the repeat, and perhaps an aca triplet in the B part… just for starters.
Arbo
Tommy Reck and Seamus Ennis were abit on the tight side. You could give them a listen! ![]()
I try to play tighter like them… Not as tight as Reck, but a wee bit tighter than Ennis, but I don’t sound nowhere near as good as them though! ![]()
SORRY “The Silver Spear” my apologies for that assumption. I may be a certifiable, opinionated, contrarian, but I am a true gentleman.
nice piping Arbo. Hows that tune coming along? “Arbo’s Elbow”…whaddyathink, makes a better a hornpipe or a slip jig?..hmm ![]()
Apart from having the best piping hair this side of Paddy Keenan, I think you are doing great for the short time you have been playing.
The only thing I would say is look at phrasing and using cuts etc to emphasize the strong notes.
It will give the tune some more punch. That doesn’t mean 1 234 1 234 for reels. I think it was in a talk about Willie Clancy from Robbie Hannan where he was talking about the importance of listening for each tune’s individual phrasing. Sometimes a tune has 1 2345678 1 2345678 and many other variations. Personally I like Willie Clancy and Tommy Reck for these kind of things.
Arbo, my brother, keep on keeping on…it’s a journey mate, enjoy each bend and turn, this journey has a hell of a lot of hills, and they’re almost all up…it aint a sprint buddy, it is a marathon.
Okay, as I have said, I am just not ‘there’ yet… with respect to the tight piping. Here is an example of what I can do, though not great, with respect to the triplets. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wiuNLpXM4kE
Sounds like you need to push the reed a bit or lean on it as some say and also be aware of the plateau affect ,where you get to a certain point quickly and then progress seems to come to a halt, but keep on working at it and it will come.
RORY
I wish my repertoire was as big as yours!
Are you an isolated piper?