OOPS…my bad…it was in England that Clarke set up shop. But few can argue with the Irish influence on his design and the Irish adopting the whistle as their insturment of choice for travel to the American shores. The tin whistle really picked up its first wave of popularity in America based on its association with the Irish immigration. In fact here is a later part of that same article:
"On the way he stopped in villages where there were markets and made the Tinwhistles. These he sold to villagers. Sometimes he met navigators, Irish labourers who were building railways and canals, and sold his Tinwhistles to them. These Irishmen took them back to Ireland, where the English Tinwhistles rapidly became Ireland’s favourite folk instrument. "
These experienced railway workers where by and large responsible for laying the foundations for the railways in the US. The robber barrons of the time were quick to grab the experienced workers and pay them for their services (still payed a pittance, but a larger pittance than the unskilled laborers).
I find no reference to his design being influenced by the people he sold whistles to, either Irish navvies or English villagers. Where do you get that from?
What I’d like to know is, who made the wooden whistle he had before he started making them from tinplate? Did he make it himself, or was some other person manufacturing wooden whistles?
A far more common instrument than the whistle on wooden sailing ships was the fiddle. They should try selling those in the Disney Store (with an eyepatch and plastic cutlass of course).
Cost a bit? Maybe if every tinwhistle maker chipped in everything they have, we could plunk it down at Executive Desk at Disney and they’d throw us out on the street.
We’re a multi-penny industry not a multi-billion dollar industry. Maybe that illusive 3-Fish Productions could pull a few strings.
Mostly from the insturments in the region that predate his work on the whistle. The so called “Irish Flute” was common and the D maj scale whistles and flutes were there too. I call it an Irish influence on his design because these folk insturments seemed to be more common in Ireland or at least more associated with Ireland. His influence could have been drawn from anywhere really as whistles simular to this are found all over the world. He was the first to really make this a mass market whistle, which is a great thing, but he didn’t invent the whistle, just the tin-whistle as we know it today. As to who came up with the idea; who knows? The whistle as we know it has been called a flute in antiquity. Even the flute that Plato railed against was more of a whistle design, possibly reeded or double reeded. The shepard’s flute mentioned in the Bible is traditionally a whistle like insturment.
No doubt about how common the fiddle was, but the whistle is often overlooked. Many a common sailor with no more storage room than a trunk (if that) did pack a whistle. As a matter of fact, I’ve met a few who still do. I just don’t think the whistle gets the respect or credit it deserves. As with many of us here the whistle is there, even if we have other, even primary insturments. I was just trying to explain how the “Irish whistle” came to have a connection with the American west. The common connection is the railroads and the Irishmen who really helped build them. Stories from that time talk about all of the insturments that were played and the whistle does get its mention. I wish I could remember the books where I got alot of the information, but it was really just bits and pieces here and there that I looked up due to my interest. I wish someone would write a good history of the whistle and its place in various societies. But I doubt there is much of a market for such a book.
While I wouldn’t put it past Disney to sell a fiddle, I was just saying that the massmarket manufacturers seem to me to miss the boat on possible product tie-ins. I’m certain that Mr Clarke if he were alive today would push his whistles a little harder in order to get them into the hands of kids who could benefit from a little music in their lives.
I’m not too many zip codes away. When I bought my whistle from the neatly arranged cardboard display, there were a few missing. I’m not the only one, but surely one of the worst.
I don’t think it’s a bad idea to sell a whistle with an eye patch, but a musical instrument takes effort to play and people these days want to consume, not expend effort. So it better come battery-operated and with a candy fipple.
On your topic - I have asked similar questions of a few of the mass-producing whistle makers. No luck so far. The economics are difficult to justify from the manufacturer’s base - it’s micro-co-branding and would need to be initiated by a creative marketing organisation who give a damn about positive cultural values (spot the double-oxymoron there? ).
So..if like the pink princess recorders, it were Disney’s idea, and they went looking for someone to produce the whistles…then it might work…provided of course someone could convince Disney that it was both a positive image boost, and a revenue producer. hmmmm…
But who’s to say they would call on one or several of the deserving makers or manufacturers already in the market?
Nightmare scenario:
They might find a way for a non-music-oriented manufacturer to stamp out a cheaper whistle-shaped object that doesn’t play satisfactorily, and market it with the plastic sword and eyepatch to millions of kids, turning them off whistling forever.
Disney wouldn’t be so hard to deal with. If we just agreed (in writing) that they held the copyright on all traditional Irish music, they’d probably only take 93% of the profit from the POTC whistle sales.