Why are wooden whistles louder?

Why not? :slight_smile:

I played a Copeland sterling silver low D once and it was stunning. I go to Erik’s site from time to time to drool on my keyboard, but i’m afraid of buying something withoug trying it out first. One day maybe one will come within the reach of me grubby 'ands. I’m still looking for the ultimate metal whistle… Silkstone, Alba or Tully… so many whistles, so little… money! :slight_smile:

I certainly believe you. My mischievous remark was just about the fact that, from Erik, being skeptical about the influence of stock material sounded like shooting in his own foot.

Maybe he just likes working with silver.

I don’t know what i think of materials and sound. As far as flutes go, i believe firmly that the material has very little influence on the sound. For whistles, i think the jury’s still open. Materials do change the amount of care we need to give the whistles, how long we need to warm them up, etc. I think the Water Weasel is probably the world’s most perfect whistle but i’m such a sucker for sleek metal instruments, that i keep looking.

How about double deaf?
Even better, dobule dumb? :smiley:

I’ve got access to spectrum analyzers, oscilloscopes and signal analyzers that can do the analysis Dr. Syn suggests. What I’m missing is the equipment to convert an air-born sound into it’s electrical equivalent. If anyone has experience at this can you let me know what I need to do this? Might be a fun project to analyze whistles and post the harmonics and amplitude results.

A microphone?

:confused:
:roll:
:slight_smile:
:smiley:
:laughing:
ROFLMAO

a Microphone, indeed :smiley:

A microphone is only part of it. You’ll need some kind of pre-amp/amp to get the signal down into millivolts for the equipment to handle it without distorting the harmonics.

You got there before I could say it… I was going to mention the bore (but I didn’t think that Bloomfield would appreciate being singled out :wink: )

As for silver, I’m already on record that I believe that it makes ZERO difference. The difference is aesthetic… smell, looks, feel, warmth, taste, weight. But if folks want to believe that they hear a difference, who am I to discourage them :wink:

taking aside fipple design it seems to me that most of the determining factor of volume is the size of the bore and toneholes. My chieftain gold hold is substantially louder than my copeland.

It’s not the wood but the characteristics required by the material.

  1. Wood whistles can never be as thin as metal whistles (If they were, they would break easily).

  2. Many of the metal whistles do not have a wall of material or ā€œearsā€ around the fipple window. Nearly all wood whistle however have some sort of wall inherent in the design.

If is this wall around the fipple that focuses wind and keep it from straying that makes for a powerful sound.

This I agree! Aluminium tube whistles have in-between thickness (i.e. wood vs. sheet-thin metals), both for the tube (hence, holes) and the recession of the labium between ā€œearsā€.
The ears around the mouth and blade of mezzo to low Copelands are an illustration.

I’d like to submit also another observation: to say that a whistle is loud is saying mostly that it’s loud in the first octave. Any whistle can be loud in the second octave.

So a loud whistle is really a balanced whistle. Give me a whistle where the bell note is as loud as the high B, and that’s a loud whistle!