What’s a good way to make sure a whistle is in tune without a tuner? I’m building one in D with these instructions. http://science.univr.it/%7egonzato/whistle/#Low
Tuners are pretty cheap, but the only other reliable method I can think of would be to play it against a tuning fork. You could play it against an instrument you are absolutely sure is in tune, but I would hesitate to call that “reliable” ![]()
BTW, I’m just now posting a review of that whistle ![]()
Go to this link and download the first item on the page. This is the syaku8 tuner software. It is free and very good. All you need is a computer with a microphone input. I have been using it for several years.
Ron
Don’t have a mic. When will that review be up wanderer?
It’s up already ![]()
Cool. ![]()
Do you think the whistle will start to sound better when I start boring the holes? The first D still sounds a little flat.
Thanks for the review Wanderer.
Does anyone know what size pvc he uses (in American terms not mm)? To the best of my understanding it’s either 3/8" or 1/2" schedule 40. Anyone know which one?
1/2" = 12.7mm, so you’d use 1/2". To the best of my knowledge, you can’t get 3/8"pvc.
I’ve got the plans, and am working on building one w/ 1/2" CPVC.
Boring the holes adds a little interior volume, hence changing the acoustics even on the bell note.
Blow the $20 on a Korg CA-30 tuner. It’s a very useful bit of kit.
I guess I’ll look into getting a tuner. I started trimming a little off the end like the directions said, and that seemed to help a lot. I’ve been playing along with this scale to see if it sounds right but not sure if that’s a good way of doing it. http://www.whistletutor.com/media/beginner3.swf
I was thinking of using abcnav is that too daft or is it poss.Im still at the collecting pipe stage,i dont even know what a tuner looks like.
[edit] just downloaded tuner software.no nastys ![]()
Alright, I finished my first low tech whistle. Some of the notes in the upper octave need a little work still. I thought it would be harder to make but it wasn’t all that difficult (with power tools
) I’ll have to try making other ones in different keys.
Undercutting the holes will help the upper octave.
Scream!
Did you say undercut? I actually made them a little bigger. But, I used some very thick pipe as that was the pipe with the smallest bore I could find. It sounds a bit flat and takes lots of air but I could get used to it. What can I do to make the sound a little sharper? Or is this impossible since I used thicker pipe?
Sorry about scaring you with the term undercut. It means to bevel the hole on the inside of the of the tone tube. It lets the air flow smoother through it. If the note is a little flat take a round file and file the (lets call it the bottom of the hole) on the side close to the fipple. The note will come up a little depending on how flat it is. You should start with the e hole than work your way up. This is better explained with a picture.
Ahh, thank you for the explanation. I’ll try that. Maybe you could include a demonstration pic to illustrate what you mean exactly. I think next I’ll try making a whistle that’s much thinner and has a smaller bore size, the pipe I used is so very thick!
If your whistle is a little flat, that is a -good- thing. If it is sharp, then the holes are to big.
Thanks for the tips. But, is there any way I can reduce the air requirements?
There are two possebillities:
-
The windway is to large: make it smaller
-
The window is to big: make it smaller (yes you need to start again). You know this for sure if the whistle is really loud. ( if you make it smaller you need less air and there is less volume)
Make sure there are no spaces around the fipple and the windway top.
Are yes, maybe your tube is to large
Try, experimentate, .. ![]()
good luck
Ps. I spoiled meters of tube untill i had my ‘perfect whistle’ ![]()