I’ve been playing for about a year and a half and have now got to a resonable level.
I’ve tried a Shaw and a Howard low D and hated both of them.I see that most professional players use either Kerry Pro or Overton and I’ve read the review that says that they are identical (Dale Wisley). I’m thinking of going for one of these so I’m looking for advice from owners who have a first hand knowledge of both whistles.I have yet to try either.
Question,why should I go for one over the other?.
Oak Jed.
Jed,
Do a search at the top of the page and use the key words overton, Collin Goldie, Kerry-Pro, Phil Hardy and see what comes up!
Good Luck!
Nathan
Here we go again!!!
Oak Jed,
Buy the Overton: Kerry Pro whistles are essentially unlicensed copies of Bernard Overton’s whistles.
Bernard taught Phil Hardy how to make the Overton Design whistles with the understanding that Phil would pay royalties on every whistle he made and sold. Bernard later revoked Phil Hardy’s license to make the whistles, however Phil has continuted to make and sell “Overton” whistles under the name of Kerry Pro.
So it boils down to this: Do you want an Overton from the Original Designer (Bernard Overton), his only licensed maker (Colin Goldie), or would you prefer to buy a copy from someone (Phil Hardy) who has had the bad taste to essentially cheat and steal from the those other two gentleman? It comes down to ethics and concience really.
Loren
[ This Message was edited by: Loren on 2002-11-28 12:05 ]
Hi Oak Jed,
I can’t believe you did’nt search the archives before asking this. This has to be a wind-up!!
Cheers, Mac
Why does one always have to go and search first before bringing it up on the board? New or different people might have to say something.I’d say, buy the Overton, give the Goldies a call, they’re very nice people and Collin makes very fine whistles.
Cheers
Loren,interesting story,but why did Bernard Overton revoke Phil Hardy’s licence if his whistles were identical to his own,it doesn’t make sense?.Are you saying that Phil Hardy was not paying his royalties?.Intriguing.
Oak Jed.
On 2002-11-28 12:03, Loren wrote:
It comes down to ethics and concience really.[ This Message was edited by: Loren on 2002-11-28 12:05 ]
It also comes down to what’s the best as well - I’ve played both, and although they look identical, the Overton is consistently better-sounding and easier to play with less back pressure. Buy the Overton. I’ve only played Bernard originals, but everyone rates the Goldie ones as well.
On 2002-11-28 12:46, Oak Jed wrote:
Loren,interesting story,but why did Bernard Overton revoke Phil Hardy’s licence if his whistles were identical to his own,it doesn’t make sense?.Are you saying that Phil Hardy was not paying his royalties?.Intriguing.
Oak Jed.
This Overton vs. Kerry Pro thing has come up many times in the past, and usually get’s quite ugly very quickly, so I’ve tried this time around to stay away from too many specifics, and won’t elaborate further, except to say: You seem like a smart individual Jed…I think you can reason it out…perhaps you already have.
Loren
[ This Message was edited by: Loren on 2002-11-28 13:08 ]
Hi Folks,
just to point out that I don’t think there’s anything wrong in asking before searching the archives, it’s just that this looked like an attempt to stir it up.
Oak Jed, my apologies to you if I was wrong.
I’d say, based on opinions on the board, you can’t go wrong with a Goldie Overton although I myself have a Kerry-Pro that I’m perfectly happy with.
Cheers, Mac
I’ve played whistles by the same maker, a Chieftain and Kerry Songbird. If the Kerry Pro is in the same league, stay away from it.
Is this thread a new practical joke, after the Copeland for Sale of Man United ? ![]()
Heck, it’s Monday morning, I am just going to dive in at the deep end!
Overtons are very, very good whistles. So are Kerry Pros. I own two KPs and love 'em both. That there should be any general difference in quality sounds plain nuts to me. My KP low F is better than any Overton I’ve ever tried.
Moral issues? Let Colin Goldie ask me not to buy any Kerrywhistle products, and I’ll consider it. As long as he stays silent, I’ll consider the alleged feud to be more in the minds of posters on this forum than with the whistle makers.
Cheers,
Jens
On 2002-12-02 03:58, Jens_Hoppe wrote:
Moral issues? Let Colin Goldie ask me not to buy any Kerrywhistle products, and I’ll consider it. As long as he stays silent, I’ll consider the alleged feud to be more in the minds of posters on this forum than with the whistle makers.Cheers,
Jens
When I last visited Bernard the issue came up briefly - he took the position of “I’m moving on and things are fine now with Colin licensed”, but he was clearly affected by whatever happened and felt let down. Perhaps we should all take the position of moving on - you can’t change history but you can change how you think about it.
Well said.
Life is to short.
![]()
[ This Message was edited by: on 2002-12-02 07:16 ]
Overton
The way out of the whole
morass is to buy a Copeland!
On 2002-12-02 17:34, jim stone wrote:
The way out of the whole
morass is to buy a Copeland!
THANK YOU!!!
On 2002-12-02 17:34, jim stone wrote:
The way out of the whole
morass is to buy a Copeland!
Or a Burke.
Well,I ended up trying a few whistles this weekend and ended up with a tuneable Chieftain.It was a good price and played well.The Overton I tried was not tuneable and quite alot more expensive but sounded very similar.I was unable to try a KerryPro as the store said that they were unavailable.I also tried the Susato Low D and found that a bit recorder like.So thanks for all your help,I’ll go and get used to this new whistle.
Oak Jed