volume test

I decided to do a volume comparison test on my whistles as a result of the thread on standardizing whistle reviews. I don’t think too many things about the sound of a whistle can be reduced to numbers, volume might be one of them.

I borrowed a noise dosimeter from work because it averages sound level over time. I realized that I would only be able to measure the sound level that I get in my living room, but the relative levels should be right. The dosimeter uses a response curve that mimics the human ear. It drops off for very low and very high frequencies.

I decided to play the same tune on each of the whistles for the test(I probably won’t want to play it again for at least a year now). I chose the Rakes of Mallow because the version I learned goes up to the second octave d and always left my ears ringing. The microphone was clipped to my collar so there would be no difference in distance from the microphone to the whistles.

The dosimeter indicates the average volume and the maximum for the tune. I only have 6 d whistles so those are the ones I checked.

Oak average volume 95.2 decibels max volume 99 decibels
Sweetone average 96.3 max 99
Doolin average 95.4 max 98.6
Hoover Whitecap average 95.6 max 98.6
Clare average 96.4 max 99.7
Susato Kildare standard bore average 102.7 max 108

Decibels are a logarithmic scale with a 5 decibel increase doubling the sound energy. I won’t be playing that second octave d on the Susato without earplugs from now on.

By the way, the Oak is one that I have had for 20 years so I don’t know if the results would be different for new ones. The Clare was the 2-piece model.

I’m not much of a whistler, but as a geek and a techy, I must say, cool insights. (I always knew those susatos were viscious!)

  • tink

Useful Angelo - but how do we get you to test Rose, Abell, O’Riordan, Elsong, Grinter, WW, Busman, Dixon, Overton, KerryPro, Chieftain, Copeland, Burke, Sindt, et al?

6 dB is double, not 5dB!

Sorry for nitpicking :slight_smile:

/Peter

On 2003-02-10 05:50, Pan wrote:
6 dB is double, not 5dB!

Sorry for nitpicking > :slight_smile:

/Peter

US standard is a 5 db doubling. All hearing protection regulations in the US are written to that standard. Not that it matters :slight_smile:

On a subjective level, 1 or 2 decibels is enough to make a noticeable difference in loudness.

Doubling what? Doubling the power of a sound source gives a 3dB increase in intensity, since if W is the power of the source,

10xlog(2W/W) = 10xlog2 = 3.0103dB

Thus, for example, two Susatos playing the same note at the same time will be 3db louder than a single Susato.

Terminology in English is not my strongest card but…

A doubled level of soundpressure or intensity is 6dB.

For example a speaker driver/amp combo produces 90dB spl.
Connect one more speaker/amp combo playing back the same note at the same phase and you get 96dB spl.

In this case the power delivered is twice the original.

To get 96dB spl on only the first speaker/amp combo the power has to be times four. If the power is doubled into one driver then the gain is 3dB.

If two whistles are identical and play the same note at the same time and in same phase and very close to eachother… then the raise in spl will be 6dB (in theory).

The gain is dependent on the phase relationship between the two sources. A pair of identical sound sources close to eachother and being in phase and (awfull Enghlish here with all those “and”) at the same distance from a certain point in space (your ears or a microphone) will have 6dB gain, however if one source is delayed in time by a greater distance or other factor, then the gain will be less than 6dB and in theory can cancel totally = silence.

Above is true for a single sinewave, but fortunately we have harmonics from our instruments. The fundamentals and harmonics all have different wavelengths so when some cancels due to delay in time from one of the the sources of a pair, some will have mutual coupling and a gain.

Something like that..

Good night,

/Peter

On 2003-02-10 17:33, AngeloMeola wrote:

On a subjective level, 1 or 2 decibels is enough to make a noticeable difference in loudness.

Make that 0.5dB or so :slight_smile:

/Peter

Pan, are you in effect saying that two Susatos playing in unison and in-phase produce a sound wave having 4 times the amplitude of a single Susato? I’m a mathematician, not strictly a physicist, but that doesn’t seem to make sense.

[ This Message was edited by: Ridseard on 2003-02-10 20:07 ]

On 2003-02-10 18:29, Ridseard wrote:
Doubling what? Doubling the power of a sound source gives a 3dB increase in intensity, since if W is the power of the source,

10xlog(2W/W) = 10xlog2 = 3.0103dB

Thus, for example, two Susatos playing the same note at the same time will be 3db louder than a single Susato.

It’s true the total energy doubles with a 3 db increase, but some of that energy is in a range outside of human hearing. It actually takes 5 db to sense a doubling of the volume.

Other technical notes:
The meter uses a response curve that ignores very high and very low frequencies. It is called the A scale. (not the musical scale) It also ignores all sound below 80 db. These are specifications required by regulation for industrial noise measurement so that is how the meter is designed. The meter was a Quest micro-14 dosimeter.

I actually appreciate your post because I needed to remind myself why the industrial standard is different from the mathematical one.

It still remains true that two Susatos in unison and in phase will sound twice as loud as a single Susato, and (mathematically) the difference will be 3 dB.

However…


Common sense is what tells us the earth is flat and the sun goes around it. --Anon.

[ This Message was edited by: Ridseard on 2003-02-10 19:58 ]

“Are you in effect saying that two Susatos playing in unison and in-phase produce a sound wave having 4 times the amplitude of a single Susato?”

No.

"It still remains true that two Susatos in unison and in phase will sound twice as loud as a single Susato, and (mathematically) the difference will be 3 dB. "

How it will sound is a subjective thing.
Mathematically the resulting spl for a given frequency will depend on what I said earlier.
Some frequencies will add and some will cancel (to some degree) so your "3dB " is a simplification to say the least.

If two identical whistles are played at exact same level VERY close then the added spl WILL be +6dB.

/Peter

On 2003-02-10 20:12, Pan wrote:
If two identical whistles are played at exact same level VERY close then the added spl WILL be +6dB.

But that seems to be impossible. A 6 dB increase would correspond to 4 times the power. How can two whistles be 4 times as powerful as one?

Measurement of whistle should be done with a little more distance to get a more accurate reading. The meter in close proximity can have too much error in measurement.
Say, 10ft from the fipple window at a 90 deg. angle or something.

I’ve always heard 3db… in reference to musical instrument speakers.