On 2003-02-06 10:32, StevieJ wrote:
The 1860s? Seriously Wombat I don’t understand your surprise. There’s more than a few of us with enough grey hair to know who Bert Jansch is and even to have listened to his albums late at night on record players in bedsits under red light bulbs through a haze of smoke of various kinds. But this can hardly be equated with being able to come up with the guitar tab for one of his arrangements, or knowing what a Chinese one-string fiddle is called.
Well, I actually wasn’t being serious Steve. The sheet music was commercially available and, given the number of people who tried to copy Jansch, I imagine there are quite a few copies out there. I was just trying to goad one of the greying brigade into digging about in that trunk to find it for me since a search of the net failed to yield anything.
But since you have raised the subject, do you or does anyone know the origins of the song? Is it, like a number of the weirder British Isles songs, a corrupt form of some ancient ballad that spread across medieval Europe?
I’ve seen several theories. Briefly: French, English, Irish, don’t know, all of the above—that just about sums it up. One problem is that no two versions I’ve heard have the same lyrics. Fermoy gets mentioned in one version which is the only evidence that it might be Irish that I know of.
Some people even claim that it is a vampire song but this is almost certainly wrong. Much more likely is that the ageless theme of young maid being seduced by older, worldy wise, male is just getting another workout here. Vampires, Little Red Riding Hood, Reynardine: variations on a common theme. The ancient-ballad-that-acquired-different-local-characteristics theory sounds most likely to me.
I know it from the Fairport Convention rendition on Liege and Lief, which I always found rather troubling, or at least spooky.
I find this one spooky too. I actually don’t like it much. The backing is too unfocused. I have about 10 different versions and find that most miss, for one reason or another, something that’s central to the song—usually just the right sense of menace mixed with excitement.