Trad Whistle tour

Here is a video that might be of interest to whistle players of all levels on the wide range of whistles now available. Regards. Enda.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAvGjNmuabY

Very useful tour, Enda. Not exhaustive by a long shot, but a really useful run through a few different makes there. Interesting to hear the various tones, and still I find myself drawn to the basic Generation brass D. What I grew up with, I suppose.

So, remind me again … which is your favourite whistle, sindtman84? :smiley:

Hi there Sindtman, thank you for the video, are the more expensive whistles more difficult to play at beginner level? Breathe control issues possibley?

Yes I would always advice beginners to start with the cheaper whistles. As high end whistles are handcrafted to sometimes particular designs they can be heavier in weight too. The great thing about the whistle is that you can find a great cheap little generation or feadóg etc… that can last for years. There is no point paying big money for something that you might not continue with but hopefully you will! On other hand for more advanced musicians who are recording, teaching and performing and need consistent, quality tone, high end whistles such as the Sindt are a plus.

Trad Whistle tour? Am I missing something?

Missing something? Ah here Syn sure I can’t play every whistle!

Couple of points (made with constructive intent)…

  1. Distorted sound quality (notably on second-octave notes) rather works against objective comparison.

  2. Nickel and aluminium aren’t the same thing.

Yes, I was looking for a Trad Whistle Tour, maybe a Dixon Trad going out on tour for the new year. But alas, no sign-ups, no packages in the post, in short no tour. Now that would have been a traditional C&F tour. More like a whistle synopsis. :slight_smile:

Feadoggie

Thanks Peter for the constructive points. I am currently updating my camera for videos and point taken about nickel and aluminium. Regards. Enda