I’ve just ordered a TD tunable aluminium in ‘A’ for my Xmas present, (from me to me).
Does anyone have any opinions about these tunable aluminium whistles, as this will be my first, & most expensive purchase to date.
I do have a TD Trad Brass in ‘A’ which I really like, but I’m thinking this aluminium bodied one will be more mellow, but with a strong sound - is my thinking correct?
I have both the D and C aluminum. Although people’s preferences vary, I have always enjoyed the Dixon aluminum in D and C. They have a medium volume and are quite responsive. My only complaint for the C is its tendency to squeak easily unless you really warm it up in the winter. This is not the case with the D. Of the two, I like the D better. Sometimes, the head is a little loose from the factory. Just add a tiny sliver of clear tape on the tuning slide and you’re all set. I think they are good looking whistles. Regarding the A, I did not care for it. I’ve heard people play them nicely, but somehow my playing caused it to squeak and chirp a lot, a whole lot more than my other whistles.
(Tried to post earlier but had internet problems.)
Thanks for your thoughts, sounds like it’ll be an OK whistle, I had a little bit of trouble with my Trad A originally, but there’s a knack to it - evidently.
I think you’ll be just fine with the Dixon A. Maybe I should have stuck it out longer with the Dixon A but I had another alloy A that I liked better, that’s all.
Thanks, Tyler, I seem to be grabbing up my Dixons rather than my others too, lately, so I reckon they’ve been a good aquisition.
Re the ABS in ‘A’ - someone on another forum bought one a year ago, & she likes it too, so I’ve sent a message to Dixons to see if they have one lurking about in their warehouse.
The aluminum C is not my favorite Dixon, but it’s a fine whistle. It shares the same head as the D and the tone body has the same diameter, so you can’t push it as hard as the D. In my opinion, the D is excellent, A+. The C is good, B+.
My ‘Duo’ just came this morning, first impression is that the whistle has a nice tone, & a fairly easy second octave.
With the flute head on it, I’m finding it more breathy than my Dixon high ‘D’ ABS piccolo, Dixon ABS low ‘D’ flute, & my Thompson delrin low ‘D’ flute - but that may just be my inexperience with it, (& the fact that I’m still trying to find my flute embouchure).
I can’t comment on the flute, but the C alloy tunable certainly sounds nice. It’s on the quiet side, which I like. There are some people on YouTube doing a fine job on it. I get along with it a lot better than the Trad C for some reason.
Re the ABS in ‘A’ - someone on another forum bought one a year ago, & she likes it too, so I’ve sent a message to Dixons to see if they have one lurking about in their warehouse.
Just wondering if you’ve heard anything from the Dixons yet about the ABS Alto A whistle? I’d be interested to know if there are any available too.