Time for me to buy a japanese flute: suggestions needed

Hi all,
so it’s really become the time for me to buy a japanese flute.
I found 2 websites selling flutes:

It’s my first time ever having to choose a flute, and don’t have much experience with flutes in general, so I am here to ask for some advice.

So, dunno which one I should go for..
Between the Shinobues, you suggest me the 6 or the 8(=C tuned)?

Max.

I would suggest you take a look at the Shakuhachi forum: http://www.shakuhachiforum.com/index.php

They are totally different flutes. As a small, side-blown flute, the shinobue is the most similar to the wooden “Irish” flute. I have briefly played a shinobue at one of Riley Lee’s workshops - I think it had 8 holes. I found the small embouchure difficult at first but achievable.

The shakuhachi is another thing altogether. I have been working on my shak playing for nearly 3 years and am only now making good progress. It’s a long-term commitment. The flute on Erik’s page (I have one) is not actually a shakuhachi - more like a kena with 5 holes. It’s Ok if you just want a different sound and a first go at an end-blown flute, but not if you are serious about playing authentic japanese music.

My gosh Max, are you still indecisive untill today?! :astonished:
Just buy the thing and later if you don’t like it sell it and buy another stuff :swear:

Nobody can decide for you, you have to check what you really need and what kind of music do you intend to use it. Did you read Mejiro’s FAQ? :

“What kind should I buy first?


If you want to play lullabies or contemporary music: We recommend an uta 6 or 8 shinobue. The 8 flute is tuned to C (the same as pianos and recorders), and the 6 flute one step lower, giving it a deeper, mellower sound, but still versatile. If you want to play minyou (folk songs) or nagauta (shamisen with singing): You will need to select a flute depending on the voice or shamisen you are accompanying, so you will need to have multiple lengths. If you want to play hayashi (festival music): There are many kinds of hayashi depending on style and region. If you want to play at a particular festival, ask them what kind of shinobue is best. Edo-bayashi (the word “hayashi” is often changed to “bayashi” when it appears after a place name) usually used 5 or 6, Chichibu Yatai-bayashi usually used 2 or 3, and Awa-Odori usually uses 7, but these are just reference. Each group has its own preference. If you want to play by yourself or compose: Whatever you prefer”

Ciao