Whats the opinion of the reedmakers out there about the thing called the heart of the reed.or the heart of the scrape ?
It seems some reedmakers think its very important ,than others dont mension it at all !!
RORY
Hello rory ,
What do you call " the heart of the scrape" ? I learnt to make reeds with Alain Froment and never heard about the " heart of the scrape" but only the “scrape”
Would you please explain what you are calling like that?
Thanks.
are you meaning maybe the portion of the profile that’s below the U shape of the tip and above the back? Its a term widely used to describe that area in Oboe, English Horn, Bassoon + some single reeds… I rarely recall its usage in the UP reed…
Sorry , just realise I’ve had a bad reading of the title !!!
Apologize Rory !
I ‘ve read the "heart of the scrape’ instead of “the heart of the reed”…
For me reeds have several hearts, because not only a good scrape make a good reed . All parameters must be good for a good reed , from A to Z ; but it’s right that the scrape is, perhaps, the most important … IMHO ![]()
Geoff wooff and benedict koehler both mentsion in “the heart of the instrument” DVD an area just above the bottom of the scrape that should be left a little thicker than the rest of the scrape ,They dont really go into much detail about it or dont explain the purpose of it !!
RORY
Rory,
These are from some notes from Pete Hunter I took back in about 1990. As visiting him would have always been an adventure, I cannot guarantee that my transcription is accurate or complete. You’ll need to make sense of 'em yourself. This is the same source as Davy Stephensons notes on his site, but a bit differentish.
-
Leading Edge. Does not really involve us, but produces staccato response (when lips are cleanly clipped) in woodwind reeds generally).
-
Median Zone. The Zone of the middle register. Governs treble at corners plus overall vibrancy (too much and squeak!!)
-
Lateral Zones. Taking back bark drops pitch. Effects general flexibility, sets pitch.
-
Octave Zones. As one thing this zone. The lower register becomes easier, until too ….. difficulty obtaining upper register (cure. Shorten head clip). Reg., reeds gouge thinner and scrape more in this zone.
Obviously the 8ve zone is the part you’re referring to. I would add:
Also helps set pitch. Can improve Harsh D/E. Will eventually ruin everything if you scrape too much. Can make Harsh D/E difficult to obtain if you leave it too thick and the lips too thin. Really the scrape needs to be a fairly equal gradient. Will bring about crackling back d if too scraped.
Not exhaustive by any means.
Edited to change ‘medium zone’ to ‘median zone’ on advice from source.
Thanks Alan
RORY
Alan’s da’ man, baby!
I heard somewhere that you were having a go at reed making,what do you think about the “heart of the scrape”
RORY
Me? A go at reed making? Where’d you hear this?
I haven’t really thought about the reed utilizing that particular term. The area I like to call the ‘sweet spot’, lies within the center third of the reed head. This area is the transition from a thinner lip are to a thicker shoulder area and tends (IMO) to have the largest ID of the reed. What you do here (scrape, sand, ignore) has a lot to do with the tone of the reed including its volume.
So far, I have found that leaving this area a little thicker tends to produce a quieter reed, and thinner tends to bring out the crisper tonal qualities. Overdo any altering of this area and you will lose a lot of tuning control, ie: flat C#, d, f# and g. Now this has been my experience to date, ymmv. Also bear in mid the width of the scrape in this area. Slightly widening the scrape here can bring in the Hard D, tune in the d and C# notes, but again it can also reduce the ID if overdone leaving a flat everything.
I’ll let y’all know what my findings are in another ten years or so, when I have spent an adequate amount of time delving into the darker recesses of Reed Zen.
The heart of the reed is the portion in the middle as opposed to the lateral zones. When people say to preserve the heart of the reed, they mean to preserve the arc of the blades by equalizing the scrape across the arc (not making it totally flat).
… When people say to preserve the heart of the reed, they mean to preserve the arc of the blades by equalizing the scrape across the arc (not making it totally flat).
Yes; the purpose being to cause the reed blades to close as evenly as possible, i.e. not in the middle first.
Some prefer a reed that closes in the middle last, but in my opinion this ends up being a little too dull/dark. If the blades shut at the same instant all the way across, I think it produces the best tone (for those of you with acoustics backgrounds, most nearly a square or rectangular wave input to the chanter).
Bill
