Paul Andry (from Covington, LA) and I stayed up WAY too late at one festival going through all the songs we could think of that fit this.
Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how you look at it) we didn’t remember much of it the next morning because of the liquid we were consuming at the time…
Lotsa songs that you might not even think of…there are a lot of I IV V and other such common '50s chord progressions that show up frequently in old punk rock songs from The Misfits, the Ramones, etc… Last Caress comes to mind
whooops, thats what I get for stayin up to damn late…
well, there are still plenty of old punk songs that still fit the bill
I’ll have to sit and think about this one, you’ve got me interested
Having a strong relative pitch helps a lot with this.
Here’s one you’ve probably not heard of:
“Each Coming Night,” by Iron and Wine. It’s the only four chords in the song.
Also, “Shine A Light” by the Stones has a I V vi V IV I progression.
“Kathy’s Song,” Paul Simon, has I IV I ii vi IV… and so on
Also Paul Simon, “Mother and Child Reunion,” has IV V I vi ii I
“Ramblin’ Man,” Allman Brothers, has nice turn in the verses: I IV I I | I IV V V | IV I vi IV | I V I I | The chorus is only a little different.
I saw that, and thought the same thing, but I assumed I just had never heard of the other One Too Many Mornings.
As can be seen here, due to the glory of Google, Jerry Jeff Walker did record the Dylan song. You can even listen to part of it. The Dylan version, to my ear, does not have a vi in it.
The Singing Rage Miss Patty Page-- Talkin’ Pat Buchannan Paranoid Blues
Seamus O’Geezer-- Dublin Bubblin’
The Waldco Bros. & Smiley-- Hound Dog On a Red Skillet
Sorry-- just wanted to pretend like I had something to add.
Nobody mentioned it, but you are describing what’s commonly called a “ballad.” And that progression is usually in there, if the thing isn’t in minor to begin with.
This chord progression is known as the icecream changes. Anyone know why? The few stabs I have made at web searching for the answer have not been productive.