Struggling with Mother's Day

There was a cute article in today’s Salt Lake Tribune by the “humor writer” Robert Kirby. He shares a few of the lessons he learned from his mother (I’m afraid I particularly liked the lesson he learned when, after he’d done something illegal, she hit him so hard with a pan, he “saw into the future.”)

http://www.sltrib.com/homeandfamily/ci_3796926

This got me thinking about lessons learned from my mother, and I suppose it’s because I’m having something of a downer day that the first things that came to my mind were two little incidents that hurt me deeply to this day because they hurt her.

When I was about eight or nine, I went to church one Mother’s Day Sunday in our microscopically small town and found they were giving out small pots of African violets to all the mothers entering for church. My mother didn’t attend church often–my father was not a church-goer and she had to balance a fine line between attending church because she wanted to and not attending because he didn’t want her to. After church on this day, there were several African violets left and I asked the lady at the table if I could have one for my mother. She said, “Is your mother here today?” She knew very well my mother wasn’t, as everyone in town knew everybody else and all about them. When I said she wasn’t, the lady said, “These are just for the mothers who are at church today.” I don’t think I ever told my mother about this little incident, but the pain lingers to this day–that somehow my mother wasn’t deserving of a flower because she didn’t go to church.

The second painful memory occurred about ten years later. My mother was coerced into having a Tupperware party. Unfortunately, another woman in town had a party just a week or two previously–far too much Tupperware partying for a little town like that–but the instigator complained that this date was the only time she could do it and everybody would come because they all just come out of politeness anyway. My mom cleaned the house, made desserts, set out 15-20 rounded-up chairs, and dressed up in preparation. I still remember walking into the house that night after a school function and seeing her “party” – two of her closest friends. She was embarrassed and hurt, and I was deeply hurt for her.

She’s been gone for almost ten years now and I still miss her. I miss her laughter at life and interest in everything in the wide world. When my daughter and I are snubbed at family gatherings, I miss her because she would have pulled my daughter onto the couch next to her and grilled her about her life and how things were–the only attention and love her granddaughter would receive at the get-together. I’ve missed her the past few weeks as I’ve done intensive updating and remodeling on my house. She would have loved what I’ve done and praised it to high heaven (undeserving as it would be). I miss her because, outside of my daughter, she’s the only person who ever loved me unconditionally.

I hate Mother’s Day because I feel like such a failure as a mother myself. But I wish with all my heart that my own mother was still here so I could give her an African violet and a piece of Tupperware.

Susan

hugs I feel your pain.

Dear Susan, you know that I love you unconditionally. Well, at least as long as you pay for lunch, I love you unconditionally. :heart:

Thanks for sharing. I think once you scratch the surface a bit, you’ll find many mothers and daughters whose emotions on mother’s day are more complex than you’d think. Good for you to remember her, and to see her, and you, and your daughter in a line through time.

Susan, your mother reminds me of…me.
I hope that despite the fact that the suburban Tupperware experience and I haven’t been a perfect fit, that my daughters will remember me with such fondness.

I think there is almost nothing more painful than feeling the vulnerability of parents. Those are very sad stories, Susan. I think Bloomfield is right–Mother’s Day is complicated! Between feelings of guilt about our own parenting and feelings of sadness or loss or resentment or whatever else on the long list of possibilities we may feel for our own mothers: how on earth do we survive it?

Maybe by telling the stories, as you did so beautifully, Susan. Thank you.

Carol

In fact, I’ll add one of my own, on the subject of mothers and daughters. (I think some of the chat room regulars might remember this one.) A year year before my mother died, she moved to Evanston from California, and it was great to have her nearby so she could be part of the everyday comings and goings of the kids. She came along to a school assembly in which I was the piano accompanist for my daughter’s 5th grade choir. My daughter said to me before the performance, “Don’t you dare make a mistake! I will be so humiliated!” After the performance (thank heavens I didn’t not humiliate my daughter), I was joking with my mother about what Claire had said to me, and she said, with complete sincerity and an almost baffled look on her face, “It would never have even occurred to me that you could make a mistake.” The difference between mothers and daughters, eh?

Carol

I appreciate those thoughts and Bloo’s expression of unconditional love (although he’s been neglecting me terribly lately, so it rings a little hollow).

I look back on my mother’s home life and wonder how she held any of it together. She had five kids, worked outside the home, and kept the house by herself (dad did all the outside work). The amount of fighting and bickering between the kids in our home was horrifying and she was constant referee in some terrific battles. I recall one time getting into a pitched fight with my older brother and finally screaming, “Where’s a knife?!? I’m going to kill you!!!” My mother stood between us and said, “Do you really want to do that? Can you just imagine him laying on the floor, crying in agony, with blood everywhere?” I suppose it was meant to shock me into backing off, but I don’t recall being particularly moved–after all, that was the idea.

When that same brother had committed some crime that angered my father (I believe he came home from football practice late), he was told that he had to quit the football team–akin to being banished to outer darkness in that town at that time. Dad then stormed back to work and I sat on the couch with my brother and listened as he sobbed “I hate him! I hate him!” and my poor mother put her arms around him and tried to make it all better.

Life is so unbelievably hard and families are all so dysfunctional. I’m grateful I had a mom like mine.

Susan

I think that you’ve given her the most wonderful gift a daughter can ever give. You’ve shared your wonderful mother with all of us here. I’m sorry for your loss, and while I don’t know that it will ever get easier for you, I’m happy that you have fond memories of your mom that can carry you through. And, in a way, I’m also glad for the memories that are more painful, because it really does show everyone how much you really did love her. Happy Mother’s Day (a bit early) to you Susan…I’m sure that you have done your mother very proud :slight_smile:

Well, you could always get a dog …

djm

hits you with a frozen trout

Mothers have a bit of magic that way, I think. I’m also one of five, including my three older sisters who were about two years apart altogetherl. My father’s fond of telling the story of his sister who came to help out when I was born. My aunt asked my mother, “What day is laundry day?” The reply, of course, with four kids, was “Every day is laundry day.” My father helps out around the house quite a bit now, but when five of us were home, he fixed stuff and took the trash to the dump, but never cleaned, did dishes, cooked (except on the grill), or any of that. As with Susan, I have no idea how she did it – we barely manage with one.

I dread the day when either of my parents is gone.

Thanks for the stories, Susan. The one about the African violet is really touching – the way I was taught, God would love your mother, and if I were the lady handing them out, I would give her one because you loved her enough to ask.

I am in charge of giving flowers to mothers this week at church. Believe me nothing like that will happen. We will hand out flowers to mothers, future mothers and those who would like to be mothers. On Mother’s Day I always feel for those who want very badly to be mothers and have not found a husband. Here is to motherhood. We all have one.

Ron

Not all mothers have husbands. Rosie O’Donnell, for example, has no husband. Neither do most of the single mothers I know (that’s kinda what makes them “single mothers!”). :stuck_out_tongue:

I believe Ron and I share the same religious background and I know what he meant. The last time I went to church on Mother’s Day (some years ago), flowers were given to every adult female in the congregation, regardless of marital or mother-ital status–and that’s as it should be.

Susan

:laughing: :laughing: :laughing: Oh wow, can I relate to this one! Every day, and THEN some here!

Well Cranberry I don’t see where what you said applies at all to what I said. I said all mothers would receive flowers. I didn’t say only married ones. My one daughter was a single mother for several years. However, there are many who want to be mothers who don’t want to be single mothers. It is them I feel for.

Ron

I thought it was your implication more than the individual words, but once Susan pointed it out I do understand what you meant.

I’ll bet Sam Houston bestowed lavish gifts on Mother’s day.