Speed Kills?

Interesting observation, Cubitt…

I’ve always been of the strong belief that one should not play tunes faster than one can deliberately and perfectly execute them. A lot of poor playing I hear is people playing tunes they don’t quite know faster than they are able to control the instrument, so it all becomes a series of musical accidents rather than a deliberate and willful performance. “Slow it down” is what I find myself telling students more than anything else.

I do think there is some “scaling” (bad pun) of one’s playing that one has to learn to do to adapt the music to the tempo, for example, when playing a reel at 90 bpm in a casual setting, I have time to do a lot more ornamentation than I would at 120 playing for step dancers where just keeping the rhythm and tempo constant would be crucial more than the ornamentation. I hear some player trying to cram everything in at all speeds, sometimes it works, often times, it just becomes a train wreck.


Cheers,

Michael

It’s not about fast versus slow; it’s about tasteful playing, versus, well, the lack of it. Matt Malloy is a very tasteful player who sometimes, but not always, plays fast. To my mind, he has always played tastefully. Kevin Crawford is a tasteful player who sometimes plays too fast for my taste, but, frankly, he can do whatever he likes, because he’s awfully talented, and my taste is not the sole barometer of all taste. John Craven is quite tasteful in his playing, IMO, but then, so is Mike McGoldrich.

I studied originally with Jack Coen, who often makes Mike Rafferty sound like a speed freak, and while I can’t that say I always stick with his slow tempos, I’ve always tried to reflect his philosophy that playing a tune should be first and foremost about the tune; it’s not about the player. Many tunes sound great on the fast(er) side, but far more begin to lose their uniqueness as they are forced into a ridiculous tempo – at a too-fast clip, even the best players make one tune sound irrecognizably like a dozen others.

Best,
Gordon

deleted due to duplicate post…

According to a number of sources, including Gerald O’Ican’tpronounceorspellhisnameinirish among others, the dancers themselves have sped up over the last couple generations. He says the previous generations had a bit more relaxed dancing style than today’s manic dancers. That’s probably why you’ll find that older players had a bit more relaxed pace to their tunes. Just like porridge…not too fast and not too slow, but juussstt right.

Yes, it’s dance music, but if the dancers themselves have turned into speed merchants, that doesn’t mean the musicians have to. A ripping set of reels is fun sometimes, but not with every single set. A treat, but not the basic diet.

Yes, Chris Norman said in a workshop that an important moment
in his musical development was when he realized that what
mattered was the tune, the music, not himself or the flute
or playing it on the flute. A lot of musicians, myself included, are in love
with the act of playing their instrument.

A few weeks ago some thugs held me down and stuffed me full
of catnip. In the aftermath I played my flute for a couple of
hours and realized, if only for a while, what it’s really about.

I think thats a case taking the axiom out of its context. “Slow good fast bad” is a simplistic idea that is often mentioned as advice to people just learning the ropes of the music and/or people who play fast at the expense of things like phrasing, awareness of the music etc etc. And there in that context it is perfectly valid.

As some people mentioned, it isn’t how fast or how slow the person is playing that makes him or her intrinsically good or bad. Fast playing isn’t exactly something new to the tradition either, check out people like Johnny Doran or John McKenna for example.

It doesn’t have to ba an all or nothing thing though… there is a lot of area between too fast and too slow.

Playing fast just to prove just how fast you can go is not really a good thing in most cases, and playing too slow can get just as ridiculous.

Playing everything slow may please some, but it won’t most, and the same holds true for speed. There is an optimum speed range for most tunes, where they really flow well, let the melody be clear, the urge to move to it is strong, and the players can keep it up for a while. That will vary of course, depending on the intricacy of the tune, the player’s abilities, and the situation (dance, concert, session, lesson, competition, etc.).

Some tunes seem to generate a will of their own to gather momentum each time through, and that can be a great deal of fun, even for dancers in some cases, but to do that all the time loses all the genuine verve, and gets tiresome.

In most cases, a variety of tunes, played a variety of ways works well, so the best bet seems to just not let habit overrule judgement.

Good point. If every set is played at the same tempo, it might get pretty boring. What really works nice is playing sets at a moderate tempo, then tearing into a set at a high tempo. It’s effective because of the contrast.

This seems to cross over into another area, too.

It seems that some players equate “fast” with “good”, and many more of us (mea culpa) can play play the basic bones of a tune (albeit with minimal ornamentation and horrid rhythm) a lot faster than they can with everything in place.

When playing with others, especially more-talented others, we try to keep up, and their speed, at least, we may be able to match. Playing by myself, I keep reminding myself to slow down - not because slow playing is a goal in itself, but because I need to be able to play the tune right, with proper swing and a relaxed flow to my playing.

There are a few tunes that I can play well at a good clip, but quite a lot more that I will try to play fast before I have the elements in place. When I listen to Catherine McEvoy’s flute (or Mary Bergin on whistle), the thing that strikes me is that however fast they play, they never sound rushed - every note comes when it’s the right time, NOT because it was the fastest they were able to play it.

For me, “Slow Down” is shorthand for “get the basics in place”. If you can’t play it properly, a reel at 60 bpm may be “too fast”. There’s an expected speed for dancers and/or sessions, and there’s a maximum speed that you can play a tune well. But I’d rather play a tune musically at a slow clip (while working on improving my speed) then deliver a session-speed train wreck.

Here’s a question for y’all.

I’ve been practicing some jigs and, forget about playing them over 100 on the metronome, I can’t even think them through faster than that in my head. By that I mean, if I play the tune in my head – not imagining myself playing it on a whistle or anything – just kind of humming it in my head, I can’t even think through the tune as fast as a lot of you can play it.

Can you all think the song through as fast as you try to play it? Or do your hands work faster than your brain?

IMHO, if your brain is deeply engaged in the tune, then you can’t really be playing it. That said, it takes a long time for most of us to “get inside” a tune. During that period, your head, heart and fingers will have a “tug-of-war” going. It’s all part of the process.

I can definitely think the tune faster than I can play it. Possibly ever.

My observations on those in my local session that tend to play faster than I feel is appropriate (a sentiment they share about me more often than I care to recognize) is that they are trying to capture the energy of the great performances they have heard. The energy in the music is a result not only of the tempo, but the rhythm and the inflection as well, but lacking the skill to provide the rhythm and inflection that the masters do so seamlessly, the tendency is to fall back on speed which can have unpleasant consequences. The point, I think, is that the great players can infuse a tune with great energy regardless of the tempo they are taking, and for me that is a skill worth pursuing.

Can you all think the song through as fast as you try to play it? Or do your hands work faster than your brain?

When I’m really in training, my brain is doing exactly the same thing whether I’m listening to a tune or playing it. Even if it’s a tune I haven’t heard before.